ابدأ بالتواصل مع الأشخاص وتبادل معارفك المهنية

أنشئ حسابًا أو سجّل الدخول للانضمام إلى مجتمعك المهني.

متابعة

Why we use 4-20ma rather then 0-20ma in control loop give 2 reasons?

user-image
تم إضافة السؤال من قبل umair feroz shah , Instrumentation & Control Engineer , Karachi Power Plant(KANUPP)
تاريخ النشر: 2015/03/25
Costin Sirghei
من قبل Costin Sirghei , LEAD ROTATING EQUIPMENT CONTROLS ENGG. , General Electric

1. Live line detection, a small current flows so you'll know that you don't have an open loop.,

2. Zero detection circuitry has to be added to field transmitters,

3. Induced Eddy currents will cause false readings.

Daniel Dapun
من قبل Daniel Dapun , Instrumentation and Control Engineer , Hedcor Sibulan Incorporated

If you use0mA, meaning, when you have an open loop, you'll have the minimum value you set in the program.

 

4-20mA is also used to prevent sparking in your loop because of the relatively large DC voltage supplying that loop.4-20mA is a perfect match to a24V DC supply.

obaidur rahman khan pintu
من قبل obaidur rahman khan pintu , Process & Control Engineer , Gecat Ltd Co. Contractor of Saudi Aramco

REASON FOR 4 mA

The reason for choosing 4 mA is when the transmitter were first introduced it was working on pneumatic pressure signal for transmission.

later electronic chips were-introduced those chips requires minimum of 3 mA of current to function.so, a margin of 4 mA is taken as reference 

if 0 is used instead of 4 mA,we cannot differentiate the actual 0 value of the sensor or the problem in the transmission of signal. for eg. cable is cut or damage of cable.

REASON FOR 20 mA

20 mA is used as maximum because the human heart can withstand up-to 30 mA of current only. so,as a safety point of view 20 mA is chosen

and the scaling of 4-20 mA is easy like

RIZVAN  TU
من قبل RIZVAN TU , INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEER , BETA LINK INSTRUMENTATION AND CALIBRATION SERVICES

4 ma is known as the live current in a system.it states that even when the system is offline ,there is a minium current flowing through it.it states that the actual current is never zero.every measurement is caliberated into this standard format.

Bilal Asghar
من قبل Bilal Asghar , Automation Engineer , CESCO-OMRON

Wire break detection 

Induced eddy current wont effect at 4ma

Mohanna Khallawi
من قبل Mohanna Khallawi , Instrument and control Technician , EBCO (Petocanada & SGC)

  1. loop check, because  if instrument give current less then 3.2 mA this mean that instrument has a broplem
  2. to power instrument and operate it,need mA, so we can't operate instrument with 0 mA

Paulvin Mathew
من قبل Paulvin Mathew , Lead Instrument Engineer/ Project In charge , KNPC- TR- IMCO

one reason is that we will able to distinguish between dead zero and live zero if we use 4-20 Scale. Means if it is scaled to 0-20 ma and when there is no process input the transmitter will be showing  zero . It will also give 0ma when the transmitter fails.

Another factor it is easy to scale 4-20 MA to 1-5 v Using 250 ohm resistance.

muhammad Shafique
من قبل muhammad Shafique , Senior Technician , Dubai Electricity and Water Authority

4-20 mA in this case you can easily troubleshhot, wire break or supply disconnect

other case (0-20 mA) difficult to troubleshoot.

boudi  mohamed
من قبل boudi mohamed , DRUK DPI 610, Fluke model 87

its esay to find open circuits in our loops .when we have wire break .give me 0 ma not 4ma this is the reason.and for 20ma is the safety current for workers 

Ravichandiran Kanagarsu
من قبل Ravichandiran Kanagarsu , Instrumentation Supervisor , Gulf Pharmaceutical Industries

4 mA is enough to supply the standing current needed for loop power and not enough to cause excessive power loss so we are using 4-20mA.

 

 

Hassan Javed
من قبل Hassan Javed , Assistant Application Engineer , WATT N VOLT

This is because in two wire systems, 4-20ma is easily detectable by the devices like multimeters.

the semmiconductor devices operate on 3ma so the current must be greater than 3ma.

4-20ma contains multiple of 2 so the calculation of current is easy in the network.

المزيد من الأسئلة المماثلة