ابدأ بالتواصل مع الأشخاص وتبادل معارفك المهنية

أنشئ حسابًا أو سجّل الدخول للانضمام إلى مجتمعك المهني.

متابعة

What is the difference between the estimator and the quantity surveyor?

What is the difference between Estimator and Quantity Surveyor? Broadly where is the role applicable at all stages of project?

user-image
تم إضافة السؤال من قبل Ramesh Parmar , Estimator , Rely Industries FZCO
تاريخ النشر: 2013/08/26
Mohammad Rasiwala
من قبل Mohammad Rasiwala , Senior Estimation and Cost Engineer , Parsons

Estimator - responsible for estimating the direct and indirect cost of project during tendering. This role end after handover of project to execution team after award.

QS - responsible for providing accurate BOQ, checking quantites against rawings and providing inputs for Direct cost of the project. This role can continue during execution of project.

 

Justin Wilbert
من قبل Justin Wilbert , Contracts Manager / Principal Quantity Surveyor , Technics Engineering Architecture Marketing Nigeria Ltd

it's like, before delivery the baby and after delivery. The estimator is responsible only up to delivery period, after the Quantity surveyor is responsible for entire life span.

Rajeepan Arumugam
من قبل Rajeepan Arumugam , Estimation & Cost Control In-Charge , Al Alia Trading & Contracting

The Estimators should have a vast knowledge about the project while pricing for a Tender he is the initial person giving the total cost for a project during tender stage and playing in costs to get more profit. The Quantity Surveyor is working based on his pricing after award of the project and working to increase the profit for the company than the estimated cost by the Estimator. 

Better to be an Estimator & Quantity Surveyor

Tanveer Ahmad Niazi
من قبل Tanveer Ahmad Niazi , CEO (Self-employed) , Project Management Training & Consultant

An experienced quantity surveyor can estimate a project in a more appropriate and fashion

AMR OTHMAN
من قبل AMR OTHMAN , mechanical manager at sarh construction , sarah construction

estimator is the one who can estimate the cost of the project items .

the quantity surveyor is the one who calculate the quantity of the project items

Houssem eddine Debbah
من قبل Houssem eddine Debbah , Mudlogger , GEOLOG International

Estimator is respensible for estimate the cost of project before  lauching of tender. But Quantity Surveyor will check the quantities in the execution of Project to pay the cocontractor company for what will be done, takes into account the budget of Contract.  if there  additionel work He must contact the Contract Authority to do amendment with respect to Public Procurment Code.

In my opinion, it is better to wrok as an estimator & quantity Surveyor at the same time

Mia Jacob
من قبل Mia Jacob , Quantity Surveyor , EBONITE DECOR

Briefly we can say, Estimator job is in the pre-tendering part and quantity surveyor job is in post tendering part.

jubair k p
من قبل jubair k p , TCHNICAL , HCL INFOSYS

basicaly purchaser and checker

Pavan Bhavsar
من قبل Pavan Bhavsar , Contracts & Proposal Engineer , Perfect International, Sharjah, UAE

The estimator calculates the quantum of work & its cost before tendering or before start of particular project. Estimator needs vast technical & commercial knowledge to ensure profits.

While quantity surveyor work starts after award of work i.e. in project execution stage whose aim is to calculate & keep accounts of actual quantity and cost of material, labour & equipments used to maximize profits.

ANJU N B NEDUMPALLY
من قبل ANJU N B NEDUMPALLY , MIDDLE , CENTER FOR RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT

Estimator is one who test the availability of the production where as qulity surveyor is one who test whether the product's quality or the quality of the production process

Ramesh Parmar
من قبل Ramesh Parmar , Estimator , Rely Industries FZCO

Is the estimated cost will be as same/accurate during tendering and at the time of execution.