ابدأ بالتواصل مع الأشخاص وتبادل معارفك المهنية

أنشئ حسابًا أو سجّل الدخول للانضمام إلى مجتمعك المهني.

متابعة

Which is better for Finite Element modeling ABAQUS or ANSYS ?

user-image
تم إضافة السؤال من قبل Abdelfattah Alsayyed , Research Assistant , Jordan University of Science and Technology
تاريخ النشر: 2016/08/08
Hassan Abbasi
من قبل Hassan Abbasi , Structural Engineer , Yekom Consulting Engineers

ABAQUS is more effective if you have a contact problem.

KUNAL NAGRIK
من قبل KUNAL NAGRIK , PROJECT , CUMMINS INDIA LTD

Both are great FEA software! It depends on which kind of problem you are working on to make a choice.

Ansys is liked by some because:

1) It's easier to use

2) It doesn't require users that necessarily understand either mechanics or finite elements

Abaqus has better nonlinear capabilities and, in my experience, certain algorithms are more robust accurate than the corresponding Ansys algorithms.  But Abaqus is

1) Less user friendly than Ansys (particularly the popular Ansys Worksbench that design engineers like).

2) Needs a deeper understanding of mechanics and FE technology.

abdelouahab mohamed
من قبل abdelouahab mohamed , Researcher / Post doctorate , LEM3 - CNRS, university of lorraine

Ansys is more better for structural calculations

BURHAN UDDEN M I
من قبل BURHAN UDDEN M I , Deputy Manager( 5E-Product, Design &Development, FEA, testing, Project) , Jk fenner

ANSYS : best for high level computing 

ABAQUS : User friendly for beginners 

ABHILASH KALARICKAL RAJ
من قبل ABHILASH KALARICKAL RAJ , Mechanical Design Engineer / Autonomy Engineer , AiDrivers

ANSYS IS BETTER. FOR LAYERED COMPOSITE ANALYSIS ABAQUS IS BETTER...

Ganesh Shetti
من قبل Ganesh Shetti , Mechanical Design Engineer {Freelance} , Self Employed

Ansys is better compared to Abaqus because the user interface in Ansys helps the user to know more features/options in Finite Element Analysis. In Ansys you can make multiple simulations in one file, But in Abaqus you have to copy the file with part in another file and then again run the simulation. Where Abaqus can be used by beginners because its user friendly interface.

Mohd Abrar
من قبل Mohd Abrar , Technician , Paramount Autobay services

Abaqus is far better in high level fem analysis.

 

Anoop Narayan
من قبل Anoop Narayan , Structural Design Engineer , Prasad Consultants (PRC India)-Structural Engineers

Both are excellent FEM modelling tools. I would suggest ABAQUS to beginners because of its user friendly interface.

Jasim Alkishi
من قبل Jasim Alkishi , Seismic Data Processing Specialist , ARGAS

ANSYS is better because it is easier, user friendly and has a bigger platform. 

BEN MATHEW AUGUSTINE
من قبل BEN MATHEW AUGUSTINE , Assistant engineer , GDCL

Both software are good for FEA . Ansys can be understand easily and easy to use . Abaqus is good for meshing a complicated design .

مستخدم محذوف‎
من قبل مستخدم محذوف‎

For structural linear problem Ansys is best but for Non linear and crack propogation Abaquas is most effective.

المزيد من الأسئلة المماثلة