ابدأ بالتواصل مع الأشخاص وتبادل معارفك المهنية

أنشئ حسابًا أو سجّل الدخول للانضمام إلى مجتمعك المهني.

متابعة

Which plc is better, siemens logo series or mitsubishi?

user-image
تم إضافة السؤال من قبل SAJIN THOMAS SABU , Automation Engineer , Microcontrol for Engineering and Control System
تاريخ النشر: 2016/08/30
Hasan Zainy
من قبل Hasan Zainy , Control / Instrumentation Filed Service Engineer , GE

I think there no worse or better. This is long process but here is what i have in mind now: 

 

you should think about:

* what stranded you need for your process and which one will meet these requirement.  

* your process  compatibility with the plc. (for example some will not operate servo valve and you need addition system)

* price 

* availability of spare part 

* availability of service 

 

*life span for the product : There is no use in case you installed a system where the company officially saying they will service  the product in one year and then you have to upgrade. (believe me this happen)

 

*what is already installed in your site: having one card as spare then used in two differed machine with the same model of PLC will make a deal in stock spare. This opposite of having two system where the company should make two spare with training in two systems for worker.

 

 

 

Ketan Bhosale
من قبل Ketan Bhosale , Instrumentation Engineer , Global Chemicals and maintenance system L.L.C

It depends on the automation requirement, cost, complexity, size

Ahmed Akasha
من قبل Ahmed Akasha , MEP Project Engineer , Bnaa AL Njah LLmuqaqalat W.L.L

All of them are good and they do the jib you give to them.

but there are somethings you can depend on for taking differences :

-Cost

-maintenance

-simplicity ... etc

Hani Othman Ahmed BAOTHMAN
من قبل Hani Othman Ahmed BAOTHMAN , Senior PLC SUPERVISOR , YemenLNG Company

Well, there are many factors to determine which brand/type/size of PLC you need to use such as but not limited to the following:

  • Type of Application
  • environment.
  • Cost.
  • Brand service support.
  • Brand documents.
  • Brand utility tools.
  • etc.

regarding what you mentioned about Siemens Logo & Mitsubishi; Siemens Logo is categorized as a small PLC (limited I/O's). Mitsubishi has many types of PLCs which are categorized as small, medium &  large PLCs and also Siemens has as well.

Shaikh Masudur Rahman Masud
من قبل Shaikh Masudur Rahman Masud , Assistant engineer , Opsonin pharma ltd

Both the PLCs are better .its unethical to compare both the PLCs.

Syed Muhammad Hasan Bukhari
من قبل Syed Muhammad Hasan Bukhari , Industrial Automation Engineer , Intelligent Controls & Automation

It depends upon system requirements

مستخدم محذوف‎
من قبل مستخدم محذوف‎

Both the PLCs are better or non-user friendly depending on the type of process we opt for. So its unethical to compare both the PLCs.

Jaseem Naje Kuttiyott
من قبل Jaseem Naje Kuttiyott , Instrument and Control Supervisor , Qatar Petroleum (Outsourced employee)

It depend up on the application .... siemens logo plc  is a small PLC it can be used for small Projects, 

المزيد من الأسئلة المماثلة

هل تحتاج لمساعدة في كتابة سيرة ذاتية تحتوي على الكلمات الدلالية التي يبحث عنها أصحاب العمل؟