Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Has someone's weight affected your decision on whether to hire him or her?

user-image
Question added by Fida Abo Alrob , Sr. Copywriter , Imena Digital
Date Posted: 2014/07/07
Mohammad Sarfraz
by Mohammad Sarfraz , Recruitment Consultant - LNG, Refinery, Petrochemical, Drilling, Offshore, Marine, EPC, PMC , Brunel Energy

Yes, its totally depend on the open position or nature of work. We have to consider this.

Mohammad Mohammad Ahmed El-Safty
by Mohammad Mohammad Ahmed El-Safty , مشرف تدريب وتطوير , شركة ميداس للتجارة العامة والمقاولات

It never happens to me . I even never think about it before. But yes, it might happen If somebody apply for indoor sales position or front line position for sure the over weight will effect his/her performance or image. So we have to take this into consideration

Shahzad Khan
by Shahzad Khan , Deputy Manager - Human Resources , The Searle Company Limited

Very interesting question and I do say that we should not be bias in any such personality trait. In past and currently we are few individual who are overweight but this does not hamper their performance or working. But I have seen where individual are over looked due to their weight issue or on outlook basis and this usually happens at jobs related to public dealing or fashion / media related position where they prefer fancy faces. I believe this is discrimination and being in HR we should avoid it and convince the heads to ignore such factors. Here other than HR the technical heads are also responsible for that because are selling candidates to them and this is they who make their final decision not solely HR.

Salma Al-Rayes
by Salma Al-Rayes , human resources specialist , Misr ElHegaz Group

sometimes some jobs , requier some certain looks . it depends on the nature of the job . 

Deleted user
by Deleted user

yes ... and actually it depends on the natural or the environment of the position that you want to hire him \\ her in

Subhranshu Ganguly
by Subhranshu Ganguly , Quality Analyst. , WIPRO

Hi

It should not if the person concerned is not  too much overweight.

A medical check  is part of the recruitment process. if a person is physicaly fit he/she should be hired.

But yes for indoor sales jobs  or that of a air host/hostess ones figure is ones asset. Here one cannot afford to be overwiight. This is also true in the hospitality industry. Also if you are a news reader , tv anchor you need to watch your weight.

amer jayyousi
by amer jayyousi , Business Development Consultant , freelance

i believe we have to stick to qualifications and requirments.i have never based my decision on colour,ethnicity,weight,gender...etc.

as a professional you are looking for the best qualified candidate for the job.i will look for qualifications and attitude .

Saiful Islam Hiron
by Saiful Islam Hiron , Site HR Manager , Handicap International

Yes I do agree with you. I want to give an examle, few days back when I was an interview board two members were marking highest comparatively to me. However, he was not enough competent as my evaluation but we did not have alternative suitable candidate. For that reasons, he was finally selected so that other interviewer bad marking hamper to choose the right people to the ight job.

Muhammad Ismail Rajpoot
by Muhammad Ismail Rajpoot , HR Officer , Mfaheem Al Emar Trading and Contracting Co.

In some jobs the over weight may be compensated (Like in management roles, supervision, etc) but in others where agility, swiftness, promptnessand flexiblity is important (e.g Technical or labour jobs etc.) the weight must be an important consideration.

More Questions Like This