Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

When you're hiring, do you consider qualification or experience? which is more important. Someone experienced Vs qualifications?

In this case, you find very many people in big positions but with less training. I do believe some jobs need technical knowledge. Then why do Recruitment managers look at experience more than qualifications??

user-image
Question added by Gerald Kooli , Marketing Officer , Multitech Business School
Date Posted: 2014/07/08
HANNA SABA
by HANNA SABA , Team Leader (Administrative Support), including translation, editing, and writing , Deloitte

Both academic and professional qualifications and experience  are important. The weight given to each depends on the type of job. Certain jobs can not be performed by somebody withoud academic qualifications. A medical doctor can not perform unless he is academically qualified and experienced. However, a taxi driver's driving experience matters more than his academic qualifications.

Moinul Islam
by Moinul Islam , HR Manager , NTIER Softwares

Fully agree with Ms Hanna. 

Both are important. A formal qualification confirms that the person concerned is supposed to have required knowledge.  Where as, an experience though adds to knowledge but entirety cannot be ensured.

Divyesh Patel
by Divyesh Patel , Assistant Professional Officer- Treasury , City Of Cape Town

Experience should be emphasized because most candidates applying for specific professional positions will have similar academic qualifications. Experience demonstrates what kind of work ethic a person has, if that person is able to translate his or book knowledge to being an effective employee, and what kind of coworker the applicant has been with others.

 

Rafael Paolo Malonzo
by Rafael Paolo Malonzo , Graphic Designer , Freelancer

If I where to choose, experienced people is the best to hire. As now a days, everyone who graduated is qualified to fit the job, but only the experienced people can handle and execute the job well.

Saiful Islam Hiron
by Saiful Islam Hiron , Site HR Manager , Handicap International

Experienc is more important rather than qualification at bottom level jobs.

Catherine Ngugi
by Catherine Ngugi , Administration Manager , Realmax Consult Ltd

Both are important but it also depends on the kind of job.There are certain jobs where experience matters more and others you have to be qualified academically and professionally.

Rania Nabil Abdul Hamid
by Rania Nabil Abdul Hamid , SYSTEM ANALIST ALOTHAMAN & ALSARAF COMPUTER CO

Both are very important but when I want to hire an candidate  I will look to his experience  in the field that I need him for  the first place then  the experience qualification will come to the second stage . 

Naveen Sharma
by Naveen Sharma , Head, Infrastructure Solutions, India , Steria India Limited

Though I have answered to similar question, here is my response on this question :

 

If you ask me, have been a technical interviewer for a long time, it is PRESENTATION. The way you present yourself to interviewer, its gonna make or break things for you. Every candidate knows (post interview) that how did he performed.

The other part of story is, there are not much good interviewers available. People need special trainings to come up to the level where they can keep interview at informal as well as professional level. One must not google the "25 questions to kill a Java developer in interview". Organizations must understand that every technical guy can not be a manager and similarly everyone can not be a technical interviewer either. It needs speech skills, you have to get candidate talking in very open and informative manner. You have to take a glance inside the persona.

Candidate can have good interpersonal skills but lower competency against a given job and another candidate might be possessing excellent technical skills but poor presentation skills. Guess in general not-so-perfect-world of ours, who would get a job? The first one.

 

So in nutshell, while you prepare yourself with ammunition of technical skills, you must learn how to present yourself. You should list down10 great words those describe you,5 key traits those describe yourself at work,3 key technical skills,2 excellent projects and1 aim of getting hired. You have to pierce through the interviewer's mind and break his realm about technology. In plain words, it is equivalent to selling a vaccum cleaner in desert.

 

Sell yourself well. Rest I can be reached on skype to book sessions on grooming yourself for a great interview. And dont mind if I say I charge a little bit when you get selected.

 

With Gratitude / S Naveen / Skype: nplasko

mohamad danach
by mohamad danach , Freelance Translator , Freelance Translation - Mohammad Danach

In my opinion, the experience is more important than the qualifications. However, we can't rule the qualifications. Because the qualifications will bring you more experience in an easy way.

Wolf Klaas Kinsbergen
by Wolf Klaas Kinsbergen , Managing Director, Designer , ingenieursbureau KB International NV

qualification is having the tools to gather experience in a good way, ans put them in the right persepctive.

 

But experience can also keep you from being open for new experiences.

 

Keep learning every day!

More Questions Like This