Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Think of a successful PR message publicized in USA by a global company. How might this be received in India? In China?

user-image
Question added by Fida Abo Alrob , Sr. Copywriter , Imena Digital
Date Posted: 2014/08/13
zafar abbas minhas
by zafar abbas minhas , Freelance Writer , DAILY MASHRAQ

YES........... HERO,S AND MODELS , SPORTS , CELEBRTIES , CULTURE VALUES, REGIONAL VALUES , SOME TIME RELIOGEN PLAYS ROLE IN CHANGING THE CONCEPT / MODIFYING IT............... LIKE LUX SOAP HAS DOING ITS ADS THRU LOCAL HEROINS OF THE COUNTRY FROM YEARS............ PEPSI IDEA,,, THE GENERATION NEXT ,,, SO PR MSG MOSTLY GET ITS SHAPE FROM USA TO CHINA,,,,

Khatim Abbas Seed
by Khatim Abbas Seed , BUSINESS CONSULTANT , Google

It depends on the message and what it contains. It also depends on the international or universal nature of the message.

 

Geography and culture play a big in PR, I believe, and the success of PR is not so much determined by the cohesion of the message's wording or shape, but rather by the consistency of the results it yields in different contexts.

 

I agree with the notion that the US is the predominant exporter of "international identity", "popular culture" or "cosmopolitanism", embraced by millions around the world & embodied by having "melting pots" such as New York that is said the harbor the most diverse population in the world, including big Indian and Chinese communities. But US Indians and US Chinese people are not the same as national/indigenous citizens of Indian and China mainland.

 

A PR campaign around environment protection will most likely be different than another PR campaign around environment aimed at China and India, launched by the same corporation. A giant soft drink manufacturer may design a PR campaign around "tin recycling" in the US, while advocating "public sanitation utilities" in India, right?    

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Today, USA, is the only nation which has the largest economy and highest consuption rate of any product in comparision to any other country, so, therfore if there, a PR advertisement got success than, it can be implementalbe to other parts of the world. 

USA's population also has got black heads from all over the world and they represent the market habits of their country there also. So, not only in India and China, it will have good impact in other countries also.

Haseeb Khalid
by Haseeb Khalid , Sales and Promotion Manager. , Medi Urge

I think it ll have positive impact, for two reason one US media is so strong and other we are so impressed by their culture that we ll find it impressive. 

عمر صلاح الدين كريز
by عمر صلاح الدين كريز , Profession salesperson & Assistant Engineer , Advanced Technology

It can study the nature of society and the first level as well as the general situation in that country is then gradually to reach the desired goal, God willing, and thank you

Ibrahim Elsayed Soliman Ahmed
by Ibrahim Elsayed Soliman Ahmed , مشرف قطاع الغرف , تفاصيل للوحدات الفندقية

U.s. of America is the dream for any one because have all development in the most fields. this country could to invade all mentality in the world and reflect good message on it, so it is good for any country if U.S company want to invest in it also it is advantage for any company want to work inside U.S America. As to China and India there is a few differece but  the development and remarkable progress made has good message on some people but not same U.S.     

Hamza M Babiker
by Hamza M Babiker , Senior Translator, editor, content writer and media specialist , Freelancer

 It could be received if sent by e-mail Fida >>>>>>

Shoukat Ali Malik
by Shoukat Ali Malik , Specialties Moderator for Bayt.com community program, , Bayt.com (Middle East # 01 Job website)

Dear Fida A.A ,This kind of message will be received under two context one is successor and second is losser in both countries.

VENKITARAMAN KRISHNA MOORTHY VRINDAVAN
by VENKITARAMAN KRISHNA MOORTHY VRINDAVAN , Project Execution Manager & Accounts Manager , ALI INTERNATIONAL TRADING EST.

In the context China will be happy.  It will explore more markets other than USA and India tends to be a user country as if US

Menerva Melad
by Menerva Melad , Account Executive, Key Accounts , Graphic Home Company

It depends on the message and what it contains. It also depends on the international or universal nature of the message.

More Questions Like This