Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What are the limitations of interview in employee selection?

user-image
Question added by VENKITARAMAN KRISHNA MOORTHY VRINDAVAN , Project Execution Manager & Accounts Manager , ALI INTERNATIONAL TRADING EST.
Date Posted: 2014/09/27
Vinod Jetley
by Vinod Jetley , Assistant General Manager , State Bank of India

(1) Interview cannot judge the skill and the ability of a candidate for the job. Interview can test only his personality.

(2) Success of interview depends on the interviewer also. Interviewer is always not an expert of the situation or of the job to be offered and therefore he may not be in a position to extract maximum information from the candidate which is one of the purposes of the interview.

(3) The technique of interview is not free from bias—The result of interview depends on the personal judgment of the interviewer. The result of interview is decided on the basis of personal judgment of the interviewer which is not always correct. Sometimes interviewer forms a particular view about a candidate which deviates from the objective of purposeful exchange of meanings.

(4) Sometimes interviewer confuses the candidate—Sometimes, the interviewer has not been an expert of the situation and asks the questions of the candidate only to confuse him or to defeat him and not to get the maximum information from him. The questions are directed to the interviewee in such a fashion, as to allow him no time to answer.

(5) Interview is a costly technique—An interview involves the time consuming and expensive technique.

Saiful Islam Hiron
by Saiful Islam Hiron , Site HR Manager , Handicap International

  • Snap judgments – Interviewer tends to jump to conclusions (First few minutes)
  • Negative emphasis – Interviewer is influenced by unfavorable than favorable information about the candidate
  • Poor knowledge about the job – More job knowledge translated into better interviews
  • Pressure to hire – Undermine an interview’s usefulness
  • Candidate –order (Contrast) Error – “Just Average”
  • Influence of Nonverbal behavior – Eye contact, head moving, smiling are rated high
  • Telegraphing – Help the applicant respond correctly expected answer
  • Too much/ too little talking – applicant dominate the interview/ not giving the sufficient time to answer questions
  • Playing District attorney or psychologist – Interviewer plays the role of gatekeeper

Divyesh Patel
by Divyesh Patel , Assistant Professional Officer- Treasury , City Of Cape Town

I agree with answer given by Vinod Jetle.

Deleted user
by Deleted user

I am not active in HR department, sorry I cannot provide my views as I am not aware of this.

thanks for your kind invitation.

hossam azzam
by hossam azzam , Fast food restaurant,s manager. , alexandria-egypt

Thanks for the invitation

Really it,s very good question

and i do agree with both answers

given by Mr.:Vinod Jetle & Mr.: Saiful Hiron too

 

More Questions Like This