Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

"A debt is good when we enjoy the benefit of Acquiring an asset earlier and still pay it over time" Yes/No --Please comment.

user-image
Question added by VENKITARAMAN KRISHNA MOORTHY VRINDAVAN , Project Execution Manager & Accounts Manager , ALI INTERNATIONAL TRADING EST.
Date Posted: 2014/12/04
shota zedginidze
by shota zedginidze , Chief Specialist , Ministory of Finance of Georgia Revenue Service(tax office)

I am not agree with all answers, because it we must calculate it by following:

What is PV of our payments and compare it with (revenue what we receive by using car), it's usually equals cost of market price of rent this car .

If  revenue  is more than PV it means that debt is good.

PV = FV / (1+r)n

  • PV is Present Value
  • FV is Future Value
  • r is the interest rate (as a decimal, so0,10, not10%)
  • n is the number of years

Muhammad Usman Tariq
by Muhammad Usman Tariq , Visiting Faculty , National University of Science and Technology

Debit is only good, when we have to move first in the market and then it is beneficial and easy to pay it back easily. Else debt is a equity eater. 

Khan Sohal khan
by Khan Sohal khan , Associate , State Street Syntel Services Pvt Ltd.

Thanks for invitation, debt is good from debtors point of view,when probability of repayment is more

Yerwant Kansabedian
by Yerwant Kansabedian , customer service representative , BLOM BANK

Yes a debt is good to acquire assets if the expected interest will decrease over time, or if the future value of the acquired asset increases...So, you can sell the asset at a higher price and make profit.This situation is vice-versa, meaning that the opposite is also true.Therefore to make a good decision, you have to look at the expected interest rates in the market and to the future value of the assets.

Shahan Khan
by Shahan Khan , Officer GSP , WWF-Pakistan (Corporate Relations)

No sir, i don't support the concept of debt because of the interest. 

Lesley Lanag CMA CPA
by Lesley Lanag CMA CPA , Senior Accountant , Takaful Emarat Insurance (P.S.C)

Generally,  when the benefit exceeds cost, then it is good. We have to consider the cost of borrowing before we resort to purchases on installment. Because without us knowing, we might already be paying  for a very unreasonable price which has gone unnoticed because it was spread over a period of time. This applies to both business and personal situations. 

I agree for some kind of loans which considered a good loans, such as Student/Education Loans, a good reliability cars (Toyota/Honda) with 4/5 year loans, and a low interest home loans. For example, based on my life loans, In 2001 I purchased a 2001 brand new Honda Civic with a 4 years fixed interest loan and I have already paid it off in the year of 2005  and still using it up to this moment by enjoying a free car payments and a good reliability car with trouble free. Also, I have already paid off my student loans within a 10 years of my graduation based on a low fixed interest in 10 years period.

Vinod Jetley
by Vinod Jetley , Assistant General Manager , State Bank of India

Yes. It increases the outlay of funds.

Bhojraj      Dahal
by Bhojraj Dahal , supply chain coordinator , L’Oréal

I am with Mr. Shota.

Alex Al Yazouri
by Alex Al Yazouri , General Manager , Al Mushref Cooperative Society

Thanks for the invitation.

YES, with a very low interest rate.

LABIB KOOLI
by LABIB KOOLI , Director of the Sectoral Center for Training in Hotel Technologies at Southern Hammamet , Tunisian Vocational Training Agency (ATFP)

As it is described here this debt should be a good one 

Nice formula given by Mr Shota