Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

The thermal efficiency of petrol engine as compared to diesel engine is: A lower B higher C same for same power output D same for same speed

user-image
Question added by Alex Al Yazouri , General Manager , Al Mushref Cooperative Society
Date Posted: 2014/12/24
Omair Abduljaleel Ali Al-Quliey
by Omair Abduljaleel Ali Al-Quliey , Design Engineer , Quliey Office for constructions

Thanks En.Alex...

It is simply to consider basic thermodynamics - Ideal Otto cycle (for SI engines) and Diesel cycle (for CI engines). At the same compression ratio and under the cold-air standard assumption, thermal efficiency of Otto cycle is always greater than that of Diesel cycle. When the cutoff ratio (the ratio of the cylinder volumes after and before the combustion process) equals to1, both Otto and Diesel cycles have identical efficiencies. In gasoline engines, a mixture of fuel and air is compressed during the compression stroke and the compression ratios are limited by the auto-ignition (fuel property) or engine knock. For diesel engines, only air is compressed during the compression stroke eliminating the fuel's auto-ignition or pre-ignition. Then fuel is sprayed into the combustion chamber where it vaporized, atomized and mixed with high pressure and high temperature air, the combustion process takes place. Diesel engines can therefore operate at higher compression ratio and using heavier fuel.

Basit Ali
by Basit Ali , Director of Engineering , Laverda Suites & Villas / Blue Bay Resorts

Option A

Majdoub Aziz
by Majdoub Aziz , After sales service manager , Auto Hall

The correct answer is (A) : The thermal efficiency of petrol engine is lower than that of diesel engine

Shiva Kant Tiwari
by Shiva Kant Tiwari , Auto-Mobile Engineer , Madhvani Group

As every one know that it is theoretically & both practically proven that Otto cycle have more thermal efficiency than diesel cycle, and petrol engines are based on otto cycle ,so petrol engine have More Thermal Efficiency than diesel engine.It is different thing that Diesel Engine is used often in the Heavy as well as Light Vehicle, for this other reasons are responsible .   

Alex Al Yazouri
by Alex Al Yazouri , General Manager , Al Mushref Cooperative Society

Agree with Mr. Omair.

A lower  

Diesel engines can therefore operate at higher compression ratio and using heavier fuel.

That's way Diesel Engines perform so well in the heavy equipments, trains, trucks, ships,..........

Elke Woofter
by Elke Woofter , Project Assistant , American Technical Associates

I am going with answer A as well

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Agree with an eng. Omair

why efficiency of diesel cycle can't equal zero

More Questions Like This