Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What would be your choice given a conflict between "Transparency" and "Economy" in procurement? Also see additional details.

 For example, if a bidder has offered substantial discount after formal opening of sealed bids and as a result becomes the lowest evaluated bidder, would you award him the contract thus ignoring the one who was the lowest on the basis of sealed bids received?

user-image
Question added by Nadeem Asghar , Supply Chain Consultant/Trainer , Independent Practitioner
Date Posted: 2015/01/25
Ani Kuriakose
by Ani Kuriakose , Managing Partner – SCM , A. A. Associates

It is only fair that you give all the bidders an equal opportunity. As such you may have to refloat the bid, OR to save time and gain economy, you give the lowest bidder also an opportunity to revise his bid.

Going for a bidder who has offered substantial discount after formal opening of sealed bids and as a result becomes the lowest evaluated bidder, you may get involved in legal complications and unfair/illegal trade practices in certain countries.

Bhupesh Mahajan BTech MCIPS Chartered
by Bhupesh Mahajan BTech MCIPS Chartered , Associate Director (Procurement and Supply Advisory) , KPMG

I will give an equal opportunity to all the bidders to submit their revised and further discounted price to maintain the fairness.

Shefeeq Abdulla
by Shefeeq Abdulla , Business Development Manager , Fluidmaster Inc

I would give other bidders an equal opportunity and would advise the supplier not to practice similar tactics for future bids.

Elke Woofter
by Elke Woofter , Project Assistant , American Technical Associates

I usually send out3 bids for a new item to purchase ... I do not need to let the vendor know how many bits are out and what my pricing is nor from which manufacturer these items come from.

I do have the obligation to inform the non selected vendor that the bit is closed and awarded,

This keeps all parties honest and I still have the option to order from an other source if needed ... lets say vendor A has a supply problem... than I can go to vendor B ordering the amount I need right away 

Rohan Walpola
by Rohan Walpola , Account Manager , Timex Garments (Pvt) Limited

The answer is respect the Transparency & fore go economy in the sake of

a). "best practices" -  ignore discounts offered against tender procedure, award  to the lowest bidder meets the qualifying criteria(s) thus uphold the integrity of the system

b). build trust among the suppliers - U are professional and rational  thinking

c). You will not provide your predecessor, "judgement of prior occurrence"

Nicolae Neagu
by Nicolae Neagu , Member of the exchange, consultant, project manager for restructuring , Arad Merchandise Exchange

 yes/no depends on bid/tender regulations, if provided such a term when launching in public.

Tarek Galal Wassal
by Tarek Galal Wassal , Procurement Manager , Islamic Development Bank

You can invite all bidders for Best & Final round as an equal opportunity. Otherwise, if your RFP/RFQ doesn't allow bidders to revise their offers after opening, you should go with the lowest offer and ignore this new submission. 

More Questions Like This