Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Radial gate as a part of dams , What are the advantages and disadvantages of it?

The main types of the gate classified by structure are:Plane gate,Radial gate,Stop log

user-image
Question added by Mohamed Galal Hussein Ahmed Mohamed , Technical Mnager , Fast Building Contracting Co.
Date Posted: 2015/01/26
Elke Woofter
by Elke Woofter , Project Assistant , American Technical Associates

Radial gates are the most frequently used movable water control structures. ... Their advantages are: (a) Absence of gate slots, because side seals are used. ... The disadvantages of radial gates are: (a) The flume walls must extend ...

Alex Al Yazouri
by Alex Al Yazouri , General Manager , Al Mushref Cooperative Society

Radial Spillway/Tainter Gates

Advantages

  • Quick operation as they move in an arc.
  • The entire water load is transferred radially through the arms to the pivots which reduces hoist capacity compared to a Wheel Gate.
  • Gate bottom lip gives good hydraulic discharge profile.
  • Hydraulic cylinder or rope hoist options.
  • Flush side and sill sealing faces.
  • Crest or culvert type 
  • Disadvantages
  • Gate aesthetics, visible when raised
  • Civil loads concentrated on piers
  • Long piers.

جعفر هندي زين السقاف
by جعفر هندي زين السقاف , "Certified trainer by the Yemeni Engineers Syndicate." , Engineers Syndicate

Radial Gates

Radial gates are designed for wide and unobstructed waterways where a light-weight economical gate with minimal hoist effort to open and close is required. A radial gate consists of a curved gate leaf, rubber seals, support arms, seal rubbing embedment and embedded pivot points. The gate leaf is of a welded construction varying in width and height as required by the size of the opening. Embedded rubbing seats are mounted flush with the wall to provide a smooth flat surface for the seals to slide on as the gate opens and closes.

Water pressure applied against the curved gate leaf is transmitted through the support arms into the pivot points, which are embedded in the concrete wall. Since the gate leaf is curved, the water also applies a pressure upward, thereby lowering the lifting force required. A smaller hoist is therefore necessary as compared to other types of gates. Radial gates are used primarily for upstream level control in open-channel installations. Flow is always one-way, against the face of the gate. Low lifting forces are required for radial gate operation, which is normally by cable hoists.

Crispin Gonzales
by Crispin Gonzales , Principal Engineer , National Power Corporation

First of all Mr. Mohamed, I am not an expert in "concrete, civil engineering" because I am a Mechanical Engineer, but all I know is....

Radial Gate,  like other gates are sliding or rolling against guides, but are curved in vertical section to better resist water pressure ( advantage ). One of disadvantage is the cost civil works.

Here at National Power Corporation (Philippines) Angat Hydroelectric Power Plant, we are using three (3) radial gates for our spillway.

Wolf Klaas Kinsbergen
by Wolf Klaas Kinsbergen , Managing Director, Designer , ingenieursbureau KB International NV

Thank you mr. Al Yazouri

More Questions Like This