Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

How do I avoid this for the future? I need your help and suggestions.

I offered an IT guy a skill set. The candidate was given a 30 day notice period, the candidate assured he was joining. I  followed up with him during the 30 day notice period. But the week of that the candidate was supposed to join, there was no response and a no show. 

user-image
Question added by Fida Abo Alrob , Sr. Copywriter , Imena Digital
Date Posted: 2015/01/27
Deleted user
by Deleted user

It's quite possible for a job offer to be withdrawn at this stage,

 

My question,why apply for new job,attend interview and sign up the offer letter which is agreeable to both parties and reject it later?

it show that he has bad faith blinding by monetary value simply.

 

There are always risks, no matter what.

 

Malekulashtar Kheyroolla
by Malekulashtar Kheyroolla , Practice Director , Information Asset LLC

This is a very common occurance and unavoidable especially with HOT skills or in a HOT job market.

Some people refer to this as lack of ethics or professionalism on part of the candidate and some refer to it as "He took an opportunity he found more suitable" . Either way it is your loss.

 

Since such an occurrence is unavoidable the best is to minimize the risk:

1. Pick up early signals, after a couple of similar experiences (sorry, this is trial by fire) - you will be able to pick up a trend and pick up early on - a potential dropout. Still this is not a100% but you can start preparing in advance

2. Have back up candidates ready

3. Inform the hiring manager/stakeholders

    a. Even though they have made a selection and an offer has been made, you would like to continue interviewing potential candidates - just in case the one offered drops out. So keep a couple as back up and ready to offer (negotiate and keep it ready)- if the original candidate joins, you can send a regret note to the back ups. This is a reverse situation of what you are going through but - business as usual

    b. Don't wait for the last minute to inform the stakeholders of a dropout, it will make matters worse. Never hide facts - be as transparent as possible - this way you will win trust.

 

Happy recruiting!!

 

Gopi Kotnala
by Gopi Kotnala , Business Development Manager , Aerizo

Well Fida, this isn't a very uncommon scenario is it? I am not sure if this is completely avoidable. His not turning up can be various reasons; 

1. Mismatch between the role and his expectations

2. Something in the recruitment process, that he did not like

3. His current organization (May be made a better offer in the last moment)

4. The candidate doesn't have a conscience

 

In the first3 reasons, except for number3, you may be able to influence. In number3, you may be able to; should the candidate come back to you to negotiate (if he does so, I would prefer pushing him out of all the future pipelines totally). 

Essentially, it all boils down to the fact that you've followed your process thoroughly or not. If yes, then a candidate with a good conscience would never back out. All the people who play such tricks are people who do not understand / or do not want to understand the impact it has on their careers in the long run. 

We would not be able to put a body that could regulate such instances purely because of the fact that the options for candidates is innumerable. 

All that you can do to avoid such an instance is - follow your recruitment process in a proper manner and if you feel the slightest of negativity with regards to the candidate, do not put him in your pipeline.

 

Thanks and regards

Gopi Krishna

Kathy Mustafa
by Kathy Mustafa , Personal Assistant to CEO- Managing Sales and Marketing Departments , Saudi Kinda Real Estate

So the candidate did not show up after confirming that he will? 

 

I think when there is a situation like this you need to put it in writing and let them sign it. A verbal agreement never works and should always be written. It should state what that person is there to do and be specific. If he signs it and does not show up or do the job you can forfeit his pay, and also write a bad review (if such system exists in your country). A review that states he is not punctual, can't keep his word, unreliable, etc. Also you can include other reparations or consequences if the job isn't done, other than not paying him. You have to make it clear, be specific and stern. 

VENKITARAMAN KRISHNA MOORTHY VRINDAVAN
by VENKITARAMAN KRISHNA MOORTHY VRINDAVAN , Project Execution Manager & Accounts Manager , ALI INTERNATIONAL TRADING EST.

First option: To get the Offer letter signed

Second option: To reduce the joining time requested (This request can also be represented by the candidate in writing and signed)

Basically: Once he confirms the appointment and the offer letter got signed, he is in principle has become your employee, so that you can keep some of the testimonials presented along with the CV until his reporting.  Also it would be appropriate  to get references from the previous employer(s)  (if so) or from reputed persons with adequate contact details, may reduce the happening of such issues on psychological grounds.

Such kinds of incidents are rare to happen.  At the most, such incidence arise when the employer's standing in the field is yet to prove for certain employee anticipations; or may be due to some miscommunication received to him indirectly/or better job opportunities after your selection.

Keep confidential of all employment matters at a safe distance only known to the HR department to avoid informal communication. Keep2 or3 contacts with him in between.

Anyway, we cannot assure cent percent and diplomatic approach is also a must where some such risks are inevitable.

orsola savarese
by orsola savarese , Area Manager , Truestar Group spa

Unfortunately there is no much to do to avoid this situations, luckl they are not very frequent.

One thinkg that will help for sure is to give less time before they join in.

 

As Saleh
by As Saleh , Recruitment Manager , Saudi House Recruitment

There must be a good choice and the emphasis on employee that is a job offer with privileges equivalent to the current or a little better so that there is competition between the old and the new offer

On the other hand, should be preferred which corresponds to a qualified and experienced in the selection of the right person in the right place

Deleted user
by Deleted user

In such a situation, there's nothing much you can do. And exactly for a situation like these you hire one more extra candidate and keep him/her on stand by/ wait-list, notifying them that if the priority candidate doesn't joins then you're next.

Take this advise seriously, and you won't face any trouble in the future :) !!!

Shahzad Khan
by Shahzad Khan , Deputy Manager - Human Resources , The Searle Company Limited

Dear Fida, this had happens with us twice and after signing offer letter and confirmation of joining. Both he candidate didn't turn up and before joining called me and excuse for their move. Though, i discuss it with our legal team and they said to some extent we could pressurize the candidate but in longer we cannot drag such issue as that person just accept the letter and he didn't sign joining letter and other formalities as he would be called Employee. Now, the solution which i opted is to just e-mail the candidate from official e-mail mentions the designation only. we don't mention salary which is the core point on which candidate bargain on his company. well, we this is a issue which we(HR) face and will face. The worst thing is that that person is being treated as black listed and in our circle we do intimate other recruiter to be alert from such person.

 

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Citi Bank  United Kingdom14th Of January20153 Hanover Square, LondonW1S1HD, United KingdomTél. :+Fax : +http://www.citibank.co.uk/You Are Hereby Notified That Your Inheritance/Contract Payment Of £12,500000 (Twelve Million Five Hundred Thousand Great British Pounds) Has Been Approved To Be Made To You Through Central Bank ATM Visa Master Card. Due to Fraud and E-mails from different Agencies without making the delivery to the rightful owners of the ATM Card We have decided to make the distribution to every individuals that was nominated as a Beneficiary by The Government Body of United Nation as a redeemable way of making life better due to the Economy Recession. and we shall send you the Certificate of deosit for you to go through it as wellYou are to make available a details of Western Union or Money Gram of £3,300 for Shipment and Insurance Handling of your ATM Parcel DHL Courier Services and UPS Services.The Security Fees of £3,300 must be paid to be safe during the transaction and from unwarranted Bills from our client. After the Security Payment is paid Your ATM Card will be made available to you through your information you posted to us within8 days because as soon as we received your information The Bank will inscribe your information on your ATM Card and send you your Operating Codes Via Alert on your Phone for Privacy and the card will be dispatch to you immediately.A certificate shall be issued to you to present to your Local Bank as a form of Identities and Recognitions as the bearer of the Funds.For your information you are advised to call me to know your Funds Manager before you start making any payment call us through the Phone Number below.You Are Advised To Re-Confirm To Us The Below Information Or Call Me Immediately For More Details: + You can E-mail here: ()1. Full Name:2. Phone & Fax Number:3. Address Were the ATM Card will be posted to (P.O Box Not Acceptable)4. Bank Coordinate:5. Sex/Age:6. Status & Occupation:7. Country:Best RegardsBrian McAreavey,CEO- Citibank Plc.Phone Number: +             

More Questions Like This