Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

You cannot develop managers, people either have the ability to manage or they don't. Do you agree?

user-image
Question added by Kathy Mustafa , Personal Assistant to CEO- Managing Sales and Marketing Departments , Saudi Kinda Real Estate
Date Posted: 2015/01/29
Deleted user
by Deleted user

Disagree :)

Management skills like any other skills can be developed at least to certain extent with most of the employees or managers. Some are naturally good at it so you might need less time and effort than with others, but you can have success with the less talented as well. A good management development program which would combine different methods such as training, mentoring, coaching, self-study etc. can give satisfactory results.

aamir mumtaz
by aamir mumtaz , HR & Admin officer , Human Appeal International Pakistan

I completely disagree as Management is something that is learned with the time, with the experiences. There isn't any thumb rule that can be applied anywhere, you always have to apply different techniques at different circumstances or even with different teams within same conditions.Yes, there are some factors that contribute & differentiate good from bad managers.

 

badrudeengandhi teenamuna
by badrudeengandhi teenamuna , office administrator , M/s.Rainbow Fashion in kumbakonam

no this can be done by proper training.

Ahmed Mohamed Sedky
by Ahmed Mohamed Sedky , Group Partner, Procurement and Procurement Manager , Al Ghurair Properties & Al Ghurair Energy - Al Ghurair Investment

I disagree with such statement.

pravinchandra Dhameliya
by pravinchandra Dhameliya , Project Engineer Civil. , Metafrique SARL

I do not agree completely.

Some people are too stubborn,shy  and close minded that we can not successfully develop them as manager in short term.

How ever most of the people have willingness to learn and experiment. If given proper training, environment and freedom they can become manager.

 

sameh ghazaly
by sameh ghazaly , commercial unit manager , Al mojil drug company

Women deliver boys & girls, not a doctor or a manager. Management is a skill not an ability. Strongly Disagree

oladele Dahunsi
by oladele Dahunsi , Project Manager , GODSTREASURE ENGINEERING LIMITED

There are ways to see the question.Some are inbuilt managers and some trained managers.To see the difference is how they handle projects,workforce.so you can develop managers.

 

Saifeldin Osman Ali
by Saifeldin Osman Ali , Human Resources Consultant , Aldoha investment CO LTD Sudan

Disagree with you, we are in the era, that people are made, we can made a manger through structured development plan  .

It's depend upon the interpersonal skills and by pfoffesional work experience

Deleted user
by Deleted user

What i believe you don't just run to a manager across the Road a manager is a survivor through all circumstances whom as welll leads his team across hard times "been there done that"

JOSE RAFAEL JR CANAYA
by JOSE RAFAEL JR CANAYA , CAMP ADMINISTRATOR /OPERATIONS ADMINISTRATION , COPPERFIELD MIDDLE EAST

Dis-agree..people with the ability to manage can be developed.there one thing that cannot be developed in people..common sense. this is the very essence of managing people....

 

More Questions Like This