Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Changes in Depreciation method will results changes in . 01. Accounting Policies or 02. Accounting Estimates ?

user-image
Question added by Mrinal Deb , Manager - Finance and Accounts , Comfort Diagnostic & Nursing Home
Date Posted: 2015/03/17
Anas  Dawah
by Anas Dawah , Senior Internal Auditor , Talal Abu-Ghazaleh Global (TAGI)

1-                                       

A change in accounting policies

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Answer is

>>>A)Change in accounting policies

Muhammad Ramzan Tufail  ACCA
by Muhammad Ramzan Tufail ACCA , Assistant Finance Manager , Eltizam Asset Management Group

(1) Accounting Policies is the Correct Answer.

 

Changes in Depreciation method is a change in Accounting Policies, but change the life of an asset is an accounting estimates.

Ahmed kandil
by Ahmed kandil , Cost Controller , Battour Holding Cpompany

Both of estimation and policies of accounting

DIPAK GUPTA
by DIPAK GUPTA , Group Finance Controller , LANDMARK AUTOMOBILES PRIVATE LIMITED

Looking at the fact, Any depreciation method help in alignment of the cost vs benefit. hence any charge towards depreciation is reflection of the estimate made by the company on the number of years over which the company will be benefited from that Asset. Hence depreciation method in itself is an estimation.Further,  change in accounting policy only occurs if rules of either recognition, measurement or presentation of line item are changed.Going by that fact change in depreciation from Historical cost basis to revaluation basis would mean to be change in the accounting policies.One more very critical point is, change in policies needs to be adjusted with retrospective effect while change in the estimate is given prospective effects for accounting.

To conclude, Change in depreciation method is change in estimate  and not change in policies.

 

 

 

 

Renato Magtibay
by Renato Magtibay , Management Accountant/Credit Controller/Payroll/Payable Accountant , The Global Partners

the answer is both of them

 

First, accounting policies has changed and resulted to change in estimates.

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Both of them policies and estimates .

More Questions Like This