Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Two mutually exclusive investment proposals have "scale differences" (i.e., the cost of the projects differ).

 Ranking these projects on the basis of IRR, NPV, and PI methods          give contradictory results. 

 

will never

 

will always

 

may

 

will generally

user-image
Question added by Emad Mohammed said abdalla , ERP & IT Software, operation general manager . , AL DOHA Company
Date Posted: 2015/04/02
Mohammed Shahid Ullah
by Mohammed Shahid Ullah , Executive Director (Finance) , Coal Power Generation Company Bangladesh Limited

Two mutually exclusive investment proposals have "scale differences" (i.e., the cost of the projects differ). Ranking these projects on the basis of IRR, NPV, and PI methods give contradictory results. In any case NPV to be equal to zero or positive. Always Project financing decision considering the factors of NPV, PI & IRR. So, Anwser is "May"

My answer is option (D) WILL GENERALLY

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Thanks to experts 

Well answers 

Muhammad Ramzan Tufail  ACCA
by Muhammad Ramzan Tufail ACCA , Assistant Finance Manager , Eltizam Asset Management Group

Correct Ans is

May>>>>>>>>>THNX

Nasir Hussain
by Nasir Hussain , Sales And Marketing Manager , Pakistan Pharmaceutical Products Pvt. Ltd.

The correct answer is "MAY" ...................

Anas  Dawah
by Anas Dawah , Senior Internal Auditor , Talal Abu-Ghazaleh Global (TAGI)

a-----------------------------------

will always

Mohammed Fathe  Shaheem
by Mohammed Fathe Shaheem , Operation Executive , Arabian Construction Company

May ........................................

KHAN SHER SHAH
by KHAN SHER SHAH , Front Desk Duty Manager , Pakistan International Airlines

Yeah, May be transportation, Materials, Labour, Land, Machinery all the things will be differ in Cost and so as the Political and governamental environment and cultural environment of that area and people  will affect the cost as well. 

Emad Mohammed said abdalla
by Emad Mohammed said abdalla , ERP & IT Software, operation general manager . , AL DOHA Company

>>>>>>>>>>>. The answer will be may