Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Which of the following is not true with respect to the top-down and bottom-up approaches?

Two approaches can be used for setting objectives – the top-down approach and the bottom-up approach. There is often a conflict among management theorists as to which is the better method.

(a)

In the top-down approach, top-level managers determine objectives for subordinates to follow, while in the bottom-up approach, subordinates formulate objectives and present them to their superiors for approval

(b)

As per supporters of the top-down approach, the organization needs clarity in direction by way of corporate objectives set by the CEO and the board of directors

(c)

As per proponents of the bottom-up approach, top management should ascertain information from lower levels in the form of objectives

(d)

Either approach alone is insufficient

(e)

These approaches cannot be modified and there are hard and fast rules which indicate in which situation each approach should be used.

user-image
Question added by Vinod Jetley , Assistant General Manager , State Bank of India
Date Posted: 2015/04/25
Mir Mujtaba Ali
by Mir Mujtaba Ali , Internal Audit Manager , Confidential

Agree with experts. thanks for invitation to answer the question

 

Sheikha Maryam Desiree  Aleman
by Sheikha Maryam Desiree Aleman , General Manager , Disha Material Building/K.I

This essay will discuss the starting points, premises, and relative utility of the top-down and bottom-up approaches within policy implementation. I will account when the top-down and bottom-up approaches should be utilized depending on the nature of the policy and the task environment in which the policy is being implemented.

Discretion by agents is the underlying premise of the bottom-up approach Discretion may be a very good thing, especially when it uses expertise of people impacted by the policy to increase the likelihood of success and approbation. In bottom-up, one size doesn’t fit all cases, and so discretion may enable implementors to activate more useful practices or to ignore policy that will hamper the goal of the program

Vinod Jetley
by Vinod Jetley , Assistant General Manager , State Bank of India

(e)

Both approaches are equally important and can be used according to the situation and can be modified depending on factors such as the size of the organization, the organization culture and the urgency of the plan. Hence, option (e) is not true.

Ahmed kandil
by Ahmed kandil , Cost Controller , Battour Holding Cpompany

Correct answer is (E) ..........

Alex Al Yazouri
by Alex Al Yazouri , General Manager , Al Mushref Cooperative Society

(e) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> These approaches cannot be modified and there are hard and fast rules which indicate in which situation each approach should be used.

Elke Woofter
by Elke Woofter , Project Assistant , American Technical Associates

I agree, e) is the answer .................................

FITAH MOHAMED
by FITAH MOHAMED , Financial Manager , FUEL AND ENERGY CO for transportion petroleum materials

(e).>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

These approaches cannot be modified and there are hard and fast rules which indicate in which situation each approach should be used

Salvatore Augello
by Salvatore Augello , owner , A.S. Trade & Consult

answer E _________________________

Mohammed Fathe  Shaheem
by Mohammed Fathe Shaheem , Operation Executive , Arabian Construction Company

E agreed with experts ........................

Wasi Rahman Sheikh
by Wasi Rahman Sheikh , Warehouse Supervisor , AL MUTLAQ FURNITURE MFG

Agree with _______________Experts Answer

mohamed badawy
by mohamed badawy , Head Of Operations , Almajdoui Logistics Company

E .....................................................................................................