Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What is the best way/ format of exporting a mechanical assembly from Pro Engineer/CREO to ANSYS for fluid analysis?

user-image
Question added by Muhammad Junaid , Mechanical Design Engineer , Research Labs
Date Posted: 2015/07/17
Deleted user
by Deleted user

You can use IGES/STEP, Parasolid format for export from PTC Creo to ANSYS.

If you have installed ansys workbench along with PTC Creo plugins you can directly open the geometry in Ansys Design Modeler.

You can use ICEM CFD module of Ansys for import export files over cad softwares.

For simple geometries i will recommend you to model in the ANSYS (APDL, Design modeler, icem cfd etc.).

You can do this for pipe designing, flow over airfoils, tanks, simple heat exchangers etc.

But for complicated and detailed geometries i will not recommend you to import. I have bad experience in meshing results are not good. Instead you should use advanced softwares which has strong modelling and simulation capabilities.

For example for structural/mechanism analysis PTC Creo is best option. 

For complicated flow poblem with moving meshes and fluid solid interaction FSI you can try Solidworks fluid module, Autodesk Cfdesign, Deassualt Systems CATIA SIMULIA etc. You can easily model complicated geometries and then analyze within the same software. Although these softwares may have some results inaccuracies compared to ANSYS but atleast there is start.

Also there are some specialized softwares for different applications. Like for turbomachinery ANSYS has blade modeler, turbogrid for meshing, Numeca turbo fine, etc. These software eliminate error related to import/export.

It is always better to use IGES format to import3D models to ANSYS.

Deleted user
by Deleted user

My personal first choice is always Parasolid format  (***.x_t  or  ***.x_b)

I faced less problems meshing a Parasolid file rather than IGES

ASHFAQ J S
by ASHFAQ J S , Internship , Caterpillar India Pvt Ltd

Model the3D geometry and mesh using ICEM CFD by importing as Parasolid format  and import in to required solver of your wish

Adnan Sheikh
by Adnan Sheikh , Software Engineer , Qapita Fintech

Better to save the model in CREO as a Parasolid _xt file and then import it in ANSYS Workbench's Design Modeler. 

Riaz Anwar
by Riaz Anwar , Senior Laboratory Engineer , Refrigeration Industries Company

exported by saving assembly as step/iges files.

Raouf Zaoui
by Raouf Zaoui , gl1/z , sonatrach

import frome Gambit and export to fluent

 

Abhishek Panikkassery
by Abhishek Panikkassery , Design & Estimation Engineer , Leading Edge Technical Services and Trading LLC

IGES format works fine. 

I use Pro E and Creo for designing.

Sherif Semida
by Sherif Semida , R&D CAE Mechanical Engineer , ATS

It is better to save the model in CREO as a Parasolid _xb file

Naveen Kumar Kannan
by Naveen Kumar Kannan , Assistant Professor , Karpagam University

Can Export Assembly File in IGES/ISG/STEP format from CREO and Import File in Ansys

Amala Anil
by Amala Anil , Jr. Process Engineer , Magnum Technology Center

Import From Gambit then export to ANSYS

More Questions Like This