Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What is the difference between comprehensive planning and master planning?

How you will make an appraisal of s project

user-image
Question added by Aftab khan , Town Planning Consultants , Lahore Development Authority
Date Posted: 2015/08/16

Comprehensive plans typically encompass large geographical areas, a broad range of topics, and cover a long-term time horizon.

Master planning is the creation of a framework in which development parcels, massing, heights, relationships of buildings, circulation, and streets are defined in enough detail to define predictable outcomes but with sufficient flexibility to allow various responses of actual developers and designers of which there may be several or many within one master plan area.

Asmaa Ghieth
by Asmaa Ghieth , Restructuring Expert , Research & Studies Fund of Development activities

Master planning is the general plan for specific project including budgets according to forecasting/projected , estimation, general framework " urban/rural or specific area of interest '' 

The comprehensive planning is detailed plain including detailed budget, time-frame, operation for each element in PLC 

 

Waldemar Jasiewicz
by Waldemar Jasiewicz , Partner, Architect , ARCHIENERGIA Co. Ltd.

In each country, the problem is within the regulated, although there are strong similarities.

Generally it can be assumed that comprehensive planning is to determine the strategy and direction of development. Planning these should provide the greatest possible flexibility for local authorities to make decisions.

The Master Plan is the result of a fragment of a comprehensive plan. Frequently Master Plan becomes a local law and determine the most important formal aspects to the possibility of using public spaces within the plan. There should be described in detail the requirements for future construction (type, elevation parameters, materials, etc.), an indication of the dominant urban planning, the course of road infrastructure along the dividing lines, strategic technical infrastructure, etc, etc.

In many countries prior to the adoption of the Master Plan, it checks its proposed regulations in3D simulations.

So much in a nutshell ... :)

ATA MUHAMMAD
by ATA MUHAMMAD , Urban Planner , Leduc County

comprehensive plan scope is the entire community and its resources while the scope of a Master plan is a part of the community and its resources.

Ahmed Abdullateef
by Ahmed Abdullateef , General Accountant , Palm Hills Dates

Comprehensive planning is the planning aimed at making the administrative units in the facility capable of production according to specific standards, that is, it is a comprehensive plan for all administrative units. Partial planning is characterized by a shorter period of time and less cost, and is specific to certain administrative units

Amir Victor
by Amir Victor , senior Urban Planning Consultant , The Royal commission for AlUla

The comprehensive planning is the sustainable planing, the one made for future and to keep going and evoluate with time. Master planning is very limited in task regarding the comprehensive planning.

Syful Islam
by Syful Islam , Merchandiser , Setara Group

Yes ,have difference between comprehensive plannig & master planning.

Planning means generel activities & Master planning means big plan for future.

Such example, in future our industry will be automotion.

osama arfin
by osama arfin , IT Director , Foam Industries

Comprehensive planning

is a process that determines community goals and aspirations in terms of community development.

Master planning

 

an organized set of decisions made by one person or a team of people about how to do something in the future

 

clarissa balante
by clarissa balante , Instructor , College of Engineering, Architecture and Technology Isabela State University, Ilagan Isabel

Comprehensive planning involves all aspects of planning. Physical planning which involves the Built and Natural Environment, Social Planning, which ivolves the people and stakeholders, Economic Planning which involves, the impact of the project to the economy and commerce and Environmental Planning which involves the protection and preservation of the Environment. Comprehensive Planning should be more sustainable and has a long time vision and effect.

While Master Planning involves current activity thet requires current effective solution on existing problem or project, sometimes it is more on the physical planning side, without a more comprehensive study on the future effects of the problem or project.

Ramy Osman
by Ramy Osman , director of Urban & landscape design sector , Dorsch Consult Egypt

the comprehensive  a process that determines community goals and aspirations. in terms of community development  and is used on large scale areas or regions across the country and we some times refer to it as regional planning though it might work on much smaller scales to detrmine the goals of this zone 

while the master planning is considered the detailed process of planning detrmining the framework and time schedules the detailed landuse budget etc.

 

mohamed elanbri
by mohamed elanbri , عامل , dilphi

In short, master planning is part of overall planning

More Questions Like This