Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Are Performance Improvement Plans really effective?

"Traditional corporate performance reviews are driven largely by fear of litigation. The theory is that if you want to get rid of someone, you need a paper trail documenting a history of poor achievement. At many companies, low performers are placed on “Performance Improvement Plans.” I think they’re fundamentally dishonest: They never accomplish what their name implies." -- in a general perspective, do you agree? If not, why?

user-image
Question added by Waqar Sahi , Manager, Human Resources , Americana Computer Systems
Date Posted: 2015/08/20
Duncan Robertson
by Duncan Robertson , Strategy Consultant , Duncan Robertson Consultancy

You are right that they are usually just part of the firing process.    If there is a genuine problem, and both the management and employee want to sort it out, then improvement is usually pretty rapid.

Although it is often the case that it's just to get rid of somebody (for example because they are better than the boss, who doesn't like it), it is also often the case that the employee is under-performing and doesn't care. 

Sometimes there is good intent on both sides but the management fail to explain clearly enough what is required.

Farjam Javaid
by Farjam Javaid , Business Development Executive , IZ Square

Performance improvement plans are only effective if they are built with an understanding of what the employee needs to improve. This can be knowledge or training, but also motivation or support from their team.

Mohamad Kamal Nagy Elhosary
by Mohamad Kamal Nagy Elhosary , Business Owner , EPS

Of course , in case of doing it by suitable way to all connection

khadija tul kubra  M Ayyub
by khadija tul kubra M Ayyub , Sales markiting , Sheikh Sons

A performance improvement plan is a formal document stating any recurring performance issues along with goals that an employee needs to achieve in order to regain good standing at the company (usually with a specific timeline to complete the plan). If you’re being put on a PIP, your manager and HR will most likely meet with you to go over it and answer any questions you may have.