Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What is the difference between shell and plate element in ETABS? Which element should be used for shear walls, basement walls, flat slabs?

user-image
Question added by Asadullah Syed , Structural Engineer , Etec Bahrain
Date Posted: 2013/08/27
Muhammed Ahmed Hassaan
by Muhammed Ahmed Hassaan , Structural designer , Cegman Consulting Engineering Group

plane stress elements are for in plane forces. plate elements are for out of plane forces. When there are both in plane and out of plane forces, then typically a shell element is used which is a plane stress and a plate element combined together. Even though the word "shell" in structural mechanics refers to membrane stresses in FEA shell elements normally can take both in plane and out of plane forces. The six degree of freedom "drilling" which is rotation about an axis perpendicular to the plane of the plate is tricky. Some use what is called a penalty factor formulation and others (mostly older FEA) ignore it.

ibrahem nasreldin
by ibrahem nasreldin , Senior Structural Engineer , ASSAD SAID for Contracting Co., Ltd.

shell elements have in plane and out of plane stiffness

plate element have only out of plane stiffness

membrane elements have only in plane stiffness

 

shear walls may be modeled as shell if it will be designed for the out of plane moment ,  or modeled as membrane element if it will not

Ahmad tamim serrieh
by Ahmad tamim serrieh , project manager and structural studies , MCT .GM Group

planes members have three types (membrane -plate -shell)membrane has in plane stresses like domes, plate has out of plane stresses like slabs,shell has two previous kind of stresses, and regarding shear wall it is assigned with shell type

KrishnaSumanth Valavala
by KrishnaSumanth Valavala , Structural Design Engineer , Indian Institute of Technology Madras

We have to use shell in etabs for the design of shear walls. 

More Questions Like This