Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Which method better fifo or lifo? why?

user-image
Question added by Mahmoud Mahmad
Date Posted: 2015/11/19
FITAH MOHAMED
by FITAH MOHAMED , Financial Manager , FUEL AND ENERGY CO for transportion petroleum materials

FIFO

Give the most accurate results, and the value is close to reality and market prices

Wael Alyhya
by Wael Alyhya , Head of Accounting & Finance Dept , Doctor House

FIFo if you want to show higher net income and higher taxes. FiFO is allowed Under IFRS

LIFO if you want to show lower income and lower taxes to pay. LIFO is not allowed under IFRS, so it is only used in the US.

Khaled Mohee Eldeen Abbas Mahmoud
by Khaled Mohee Eldeen Abbas Mahmoud , Chartered Accountant # 10465 , Self-employed

both are ok to use with respect to goods type

Deleted user
by Deleted user

FIFO : In this method inventory is valued as per current price and would give a much accurate figure than the LIFO method.

Abdulqadir Sunelwala
by Abdulqadir Sunelwala , Audit Associate , Mustafa & Co.

As per  AS-2 valuation of inventory, stock should be valued at cost or net realizable value whichever is lower. Further as per AS-2 FIFO and weighted average method for inventory valuation are recommended & exclusively permissible ruling out the LIFO method because of following reasons

It does not give a fair value of stock which is comparable to market value.

The inflated price or deflation in price is not reflected in LIFO method

The stock valued on LIFO basis is unrealistic & do not give a correct position of stock.

As against FIFO & weighted average the stock is valued on basis of old stock rates which were purchased earlier in the business though actual stock lying would be from the current inventory procured.

therefore due to following reasons LIFO method is mostly not suggested for inventory valuation 

More Questions Like This