Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What is the sum of digit depreciation method is better than reducing balance method?

user-image
Question added by Wasim khan wazir , Finance Specialist , Mott Macdonald
Date Posted: 2016/03/26
Shahbaz Hayder
by Shahbaz Hayder , Group Head of Finance , Sharif Group of Companies

The both are accelerated depreciation methods.

 

Now it depends upon the objective of the company. For example, the objective is to reduce the reported profit of a business in near term. If you want to do it aggressively, sum of years’ digits method is good otherwise reducing balance method is the appropriate choice.

 

Also see the reporting and regulatory requirements of the respective territory before choosing a depreciation method.

Abu Bakar Ashfaq
by Abu Bakar Ashfaq , Senior Consultant , PricewaterhouseCoopers Middle East

Agreed with Mr. Shahbaz answer

Mohammad Iqbal Abubaker
by Mohammad Iqbal Abubaker , Jahaca Pty Ltd - Accounts Administrator , Jahaca Pty Ltd - Accounts Administrator

 I agree with the answer given by Shahbaz Hayder   Chief Financial Officer. His answer is very CORRECT.

Mohammed Shahsad
by Mohammed Shahsad , Freelance Travel Consultant , Freelancing

true, Straight Line depreciation is easy to account and calculate than reduced balance or written-down value method. but if you consider Straight line some day the value of asset will be 'Zero' . In case of writtendown Value method asset value is unlimited, unless asset is sold or written off. 

HASSAN AHMED
by HASSAN AHMED , Internal Auditor , TIE

Option B is correct because it is not good practice to neglect salvage value of an asset. Depreciation methods differs as per nature of an asset, We can not implement same method on all.

حسين محمد ياسين
by حسين محمد ياسين , Finance Manager , مؤسسة عبد الماجد محمد العمر للمقاولات العامة

B >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

georgei assi
by georgei assi , مدير حسابات , المجموعة السورية

 

 

B. False

It's a mistake to exclude scrap value at the end of use and the difficulty in determining the useful life of the asset

 

 

FARES AHMMED SHARF AL-AKHALI
by FARES AHMMED SHARF AL-AKHALI , محاسب قانوني معتمد , فارس الأكحلي محاسب قانوني معتمد

Thank you........Option .B

Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi
by Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi , Shared Services Supervisor , Saudi Musheera Co. Ltd.

Option " 2 " False

                .

Mohamed Hakeem Meerashahib
by Mohamed Hakeem Meerashahib , Branch Manager , Sri Lanka State Trading (General) Corporation

Option B. False is the correct answer

Mohammad Ashi CFA CMA
by Mohammad Ashi CFA CMA , Group Finance Manager , QOAD

false, as described by Mr. Georgi Assi

More Questions Like This