Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Can we use PLC instead of relays?

user-image
Question added by Muhammad Usman Raza , Trainee Engineer , Tri-Tech
Date Posted: 2016/03/27
AMR Mohamed Refat
by AMR Mohamed Refat , Plant Manager , KOC

If you mean in a simple applications the answer will be yes but not economic and if you mean in a big applications then the question will not make a logic , It is look like saying can I use a donkey instead of a car !!!!

 

Fadi Al-Madi
by Fadi Al-Madi , Project & Continuous Improvement Manager , NFPC

the main aim for the PLC optimize the hardware , yes sure you can do that .

Khalid  Imtiaz
by Khalid Imtiaz , Sr.Project Engineer , INTECH Automation & Intelligence

RELAY IS USED JUST AS SWITCHING BUT THE PLC IS USED FOR LARGER APPLICATION OF RELAY LOGIC. 

Bill Kevin Paquiz
by Bill Kevin Paquiz , Service Engineer , RUAG Defence

Of course. For large scale operations, PLC is more applicable. But for small scale operations, it is more cost efficient to use Relays.

Sivaprasad M P
by Sivaprasad M P , Maintenance Engineer/Technician , Guardian Safety And Security LLC

Yes we can efficiently replace relays using plc

PLC can perform in different environments and it consumes small area for installation.

Also it can handle more number of operation at a time.

ARUN  MOHAN
by ARUN MOHAN , Data Center Operations Engineer , Engie Solutions Middle East

Actually P.L.C is replacement of relays.Which reduces complexity of circuits.If we use relays for big applications it will make things more complex 

Mahfoud Bensadoun
by Mahfoud Bensadoun , Maintenance Technician , TAPIDOR

yes we can ; but we take in consideration the over all price and efficiency

MUBASHIR AHMED KHAN MOHAMMED
by MUBASHIR AHMED KHAN MOHAMMED , Senior Engineer , Sendan International

Yes we can use  but with some limitations. You can select  and replace with I/O Modules depending upon existing Relay specifications.

Waqar Younas
by Waqar Younas , Internee Engineer , Nestle (Kabirwala Factory)

Yes,PLC is modified form of Relays .relay controlled by manually and with PLC we control the process trough Programming

Muahmmad Arif
by Muahmmad Arif , Operation & Maintenance / Planning Engineer , Bestway Cement

If you are using only for control then yes you can use but if you want to use for control and protection then not possible. 

Ahmed Akasha
by Ahmed Akasha , MEP Project Engineer , Bnaa AL Njah LLmuqaqalat W.L.L

PLCs perform the same function as relays, but can do so much more. They can be put to great use when old relay panels need to be modernized, or when new systems need an elegant means of control.If the electrical control system has only a few inputs and outputs and the logic requirements are simple ON/OFF control, then relays can do the job just fine without a PLC. But if a dozen or more digital I/O are required (and maybe even some analog signals), then PLCs are the way to go. Each electrical device (input or output signal) is wired its own terminal point.

More Questions Like This