Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Potential drawbacks of private warehouses includes: (3 things), what are they?

    A) Maximize the usage of available storage space    B) High fixed cost.    Necessity of having high and steady demand volumes.    May reduce an organization's flexibility.    C)1) Fixed versus variable slot locations for merchandise   2) build out (horizontal) versus build up (vertical)   3) order-picking versus stock-replenishing functions   4) two-dock versus single-dock layout   5) conventional, narrow, or very narrow aisles   6) paperless warehousing vs. traditional paper-oriented warehousing operations   7) other space needs   D) MANY props to you if you can remember all this!!    Longer-Haul. Sorry if that question made absolutely no sense.

user-image
Question added by Wasi Rahman Sheikh , Warehouse Supervisor , AL MUTLAQ FURNITURE MFG
Date Posted: 2016/04/12
Rafi Shajahan
by Rafi Shajahan , Supply Chain Coordinator , QATAR AIRWAYS

OPtion B is the answer

 

B) High fixed cost.    Necessity of having high and steady demand volumes.    May reduce an organization's flexibility.

ACHMAD SURJANI
by ACHMAD SURJANI , General Manager Operations , Sinar Jaya Group Ltd

Warehousing Options: Choosing the Right One for a Company

There are three main options for warehousing: public, contract and private. Here are the highlights of the basic differences among them:

  1. Public Warehousing: Space is leased month-to-month for a fixed fee per square foot. The advantage of public warehousing is that there are no long-term commitments. The disadvantage is that this option is often the most expensive per square foot
  2. Contract Warehousing: Space is leased for a fixed term, usually six months or longer. The cost per square foot is generally better than for public warehousing, and the space often comes with features such as racking, forklifts, dedicated docks and 24-hour security
  3. Private Warehousing: Space is owned and managed by the business. The main advantage to owning the space is the potential for total control of all aspects of the operation, including leasing out unused space. The biggest downside to private warehousing is the capital needed to acquire the space and the cash flow to manage it

How to Choose the Best Warehousing Option

Beyond the basic differences described above, there are a host of other factors to consider:

  • Purpose: Will the warehouse be a cost or a profit center?
  • Duration: How long will goods be housed? Will goods enter once and remain for an extended period (storage), or will there be many shipments received and sent from the warehouse? Is this need temporary or permanent?
  • Location: Does the warehouse need to be close to a transportation corridor such as a rail line or a port? Or does it make more sense to have a warehouse located near a primary customer or the company office? As fuel costs continue to rise, the location of warehousing is not just a matter of convenience, but is strategic to the profitability of the enterprise
  • Access: How often will the warehouse receive shipments? How often will the goods stored be accessed? Who needs access to the building and when?
  • Services: Does the business require specialized services such as ultraclean storage, cold storage, a communications system, the ability to generate documentation, and so on?
  • Costs: The cost per square foot is only one factor in the calculation of the overall cost of warehousing. All the factors listed above contribute to that calculation as does consideration of taxes (no taxes on public storage, but a possible tax benefit for private warehousing)

Mohamed Helal
by Mohamed Helal , Project Manager , GROUP CONSULT INTERNATIONAL

Actually don't have clear answer...prefer to wait for answers by professionals

Mohammed  Ashraf
by Mohammed Ashraf , Director of International Business , Saqr Al-Khayala Group

b...........................................,,,,,,,,,..........................................

Nadeem Asghar
by Nadeem Asghar , Supply Chain Consultant/Trainer , Independent Practitioner

Not clear to me so better not to guess.

Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi
by Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi , Shared Services Supervisor , Saudi Musheera Co. Ltd.

agree with expert answers above

High fixed cost.    Necessity of having high and steady demand volumes.    May reduce an organization's flexibilit _____________I guesses answer 

C)1) Fixed versus variable slot locations for merchandise   2) build out (horizontal) versus build up (vertical)   3) order-picking versus stock-replenishing functions

Saiyid Maududi-Oracle Applications Consultant
by Saiyid Maududi-Oracle Applications Consultant , Entrerprise Architect , US Technomatrix, Inc

Hello Team,

Disadvantages of public warehousing

1. Problems in communication due to system incompatibility

2. Specialized services may not always be available whenever it is needed.

3. Adequate space may not always be available for end Disadvantages of private warehousing

1.    Lack of Corporate flexibility which increases the complexity in the operation.

2.    Financial issues

3.    Low rate of return.

4.    Tax issues are complicated.

The graph below clearly shows the impact of fixed costs with reference to volume of goods handled in public warehouse as well as in private warehouse. The organization has to take a strategic decision in the selection of type of warehouse which would suit its corporate goal. The organization has to ascertain the volume of goods to be handled in their business plan in order to decide on the type of warehouse.

In practice, it is desirable to use both private and public warehousing according to the products and customer base. Also, private warehouses need not be owned. They may be rented or leased with or without material handling and other office equipment.

Regards,

 

Saiyid

More Questions Like This