Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

A firm short of cash might well give greater emphasis to the payback period in evaluating a project. ( true or false )?

user-image
Question added by Moataz Elhariry , Chief of Financial Controlling& Development Department , Alhasan Alnaamy Group
Date Posted: 2016/05/25
Duncan Robertson
by Duncan Robertson , Strategy Consultant , Duncan Robertson Consultancy

No, no, no, this question makes no sense at all.  A firm that is short of cash would NEVER consider a project that does not have a very, very quick payback period for the simple reason that they would go bust. 

Or, to give a real world example,

"I can't pay the rent tomorrow because I'm short of cash.  My options are:

1) Go to night school classes and obtain a business qualification, then get a better job which will make paying the rent easy and leave money for luxuries

2) Sell my car which I can't afford to run anyway.

Hmmm, what to do, what to do ...... "

Shameer Nazir Madari
by Shameer Nazir Madari , Assistant Finance Manager , METAL AND RECYCLING COMPANY K.S.C. (PUBLIC)

 

A firm short of cash might well give greater emphasis to the payback period in evaluating a project.

 

Answer is True

 

mohammed negm
by mohammed negm , مدير مبيعات , مؤسسة أطياف لتجارة المواد الغذائية

I agree with  Duncan Robertson answers, thanks for the invitation

Tamer Elbeshbishy
by Tamer Elbeshbishy , Financial and Administration Manager , Muscat Towers Holding Group

One of the great limitations on Payback Period in evaluating projects, is that it doesn’t consider the timing of the inflows, i.e. amount of the cash income and does not consider the risk or the present value of money. In my opinion, in any project we should consider other alternatives in the evaluation, like present value, or Internal rate of return. Payback period is not the basic that should be used in projects, but we can use it as an indicator.

Please note also that it is important to estimate your cash budget before starting your project, to maintain the running of the process. lack or shortage of cash will STOP the progress of your project. Thank You .

 

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Depending on the type of project

An estimate payback period

And the usefulness of the project

Zaheer uddin Raja
by Zaheer uddin Raja , Accounts Supervisor , Pakistan International Airlines

True. Viable Projects with early payback periods may be given priority in these circumstances.

Muhammad  Sohail
by Muhammad Sohail , Chief Engineer , Pir Mehr Ali Shah – University of Arid Agriculture Rawalpindi

False.

The firm should either look for earn guarantees fro the banks or switch over to consultancies.

Ksenija Kancelak
by Ksenija Kancelak , Construction Project Manager , City of Koprivnica, Koprivnica (Croatia)

I presume that the right answer is:

True!

I leave the answer experts Specialist in this field .

More Questions Like This