Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Why it is not recommended to have the Infrastrure role on the Global Catalogue ?

user-image
Question added by Hamza KHEDADJI , Senior System and Cloud Engineer , Neptune Energy
Date Posted: 2016/05/31
Shaik Tharim Kharni
by Shaik Tharim Kharni , IT Solutions Professional , GulfNet Solutions Company Limited

Because Infrastructure master performs its task by comparing its state against the state of a GC - and updates other DCs in the same domain based on the outcome. Effectively, the update would never took place since no differences would be detected...!!!!

Hope this clarifies your question.

Shaik

Periyasamy s
by Periyasamy s , Assistant Manager , Futurisk Insurance Broking Company Pvt Ltd

If the infrastructure master and global catalog are on the same domain controller, theinfrastructure master will not function. The infrastructure master will never find data that is out of date, so will never replicate any changes to the other domain controllers in the domain.

If all of the domain controllers in a domain are also hosting the global catalog, all of the domain controllers will have the current data and it does not matter which domain controller holds the infrastructure master role.

 we have the Infrastructure role on our 2008 DC, which is a GC.

Khurram Shahzad
by Khurram Shahzad , Senior IT consultant , Austroconsult LLC

The IM is responsible for updating cross-domain object references each DC in the Domain, to do that it needs to check for changes on an available GC, then compares its information with the information that the GC has, if any changes, then updates its local information, and updates cross-domain object references each DC in the Domain.- The Problem is that If the IM is also a GC, when is going to check for  changes he asks for a GC and because the IM is also a GC it "thinks" that it  has all information updated and there's no need to update the DCs on its domain causing others DCs ending up with nonupdated information, remember  DCs in a domain only know everything about their domain, because the domain  partition is replicated between them.

Mohammed Ibrahim Koppuli
by Mohammed Ibrahim Koppuli , Senior Exchange Administrator , Ministry Of Education - Saudi Arabia

Because phantom object will not be updated. This phantom object is a special kind of object it stores cross reference object when infrastructure master update from another domain.

If the infrastructure master role holder is also a global catalog server, the phantom indexes are never created or updated on that domain controller. This behavior occurs because a global catalog server contains partial replica of every object in Active Directory. Infrastructure master does not store phantom versions of the foreign objects because it already has a partial replica of the object in the local global catalog. For this process to work correctly in a multi domain environment, the infrastructure master role holder cannot be a global catalog server. Be aware that the first domain controller in the forest holds all the five FSMO roles and is also a global catalog. Therefore, we must transfer either role to another computer as soon as another domain controller is installed in the domain if you plan to have multiple domains.

 

sineesh mathew
by sineesh mathew , Technical product Support Engineer , Techzo Simply solutions

it will check difference of global catalog,if they are in same dc it will not find any change

More Questions Like This