Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Ahmed want to construct a house. He engages an architect-cum-builder. What kind of contract should Ahmed go for to have minimum risk for himself?

A.  Lumpsum 

B.  Cost plus fixed fee 

C.  Cost plus % fee 

Cost plus incentive fee

user-image
Question added by Muhammad Farooq , QA-QC MANAGER , AL Bawani contracting co.
Date Posted: 2016/06/25
Md Fazlur Rahman
by Md Fazlur Rahman , Procurement Specialist , Engineering and Planning Consultants Ltd

Mr. Ahmed shall get the layout, plan and design and ensure his preferred choice and functionality of the house.

Then he shall get the itemised unit cost and total cost of all items with detailed specification of construction materials, equipment to be used, security issues, and workmanship with reference to some approved international standard. Then to arrive at a total cost of building.

An arbitration clause as per law of the country must be inserted to protect the interest of both the parties.

Thereafter, he must negotiate completion time and payment terms.

Finally, He shall put a supervisory clause that work must be done as per agreed specifications. Any changes in design and cost during construction period must be agreed by both parties in writing.

So, basically it should be Lump Sum(fixed price) contract with provision for changes as agreed by both parties during construction.  

 

Ksenija Kancelak
by Ksenija Kancelak , Construction Project Manager , City of Koprivnica, Koprivnica (Croatia)

My opinion is that the right answer is:

a

Amin ALMASRI
by Amin ALMASRI , Procurement Manager , Dur Hospitality Co.

Turn Key Lump sum Contract.

Krishna   KHASANIS  PMP
by Krishna KHASANIS PMP , Project Manager-Electrical , Larsen & Toubro Ltd, P T & D (International)

In Lumpsum ( Firm Fixed Price ) type of contract Ahmed has minimum risk for himself. 

Ramzi SAMRI
by Ramzi SAMRI , Industrial engineer , Institut für Betriebliche Bildungsforschung Berlin (IBBF)

A is the suitable answer. Thanks

Mohamed Helal
by Mohamed Helal , Project Manager , GROUP CONSULT INTERNATIONAL

A.  Lumpsum ..................

Usman Islam
by Usman Islam , Logistics And Warehouse Manager , Kirtanlal Scaffolding & Formwork

Option A is best choice........

sardar mardookhy
by sardar mardookhy , Head of portfolio management department , MCI

Option A............... lowest risk

Ghulam Murtaza
by Ghulam Murtaza , Head of Digital , Naubahar Bottling Company Private Limited

B. Cost plus fixed fee - This contact will not bound him in selection of material, he can choose whatever fits to his budget. Contractor fee will be fixed so there is no risk for unwanted price increase 

MUSTAFIZUR RAHMAN
by MUSTAFIZUR RAHMAN , Senior Merchandiser , Ultimate Fashions Limited.

B. Cost plus fixed fee. So that the owner can have confident in his own material and the architect don't need to worry about quality of material. He can work freely with best effort.

Abdallah Makahleh
by Abdallah Makahleh , Supply chain and contracts management , MERAS International

Conditions on an Architect are different from conditions implied on a project manager consultant or a contractor. Generally design drawings are always subjected to change orders either due to the request of the client or the welfare of the project, accordingly if the designer is engaged in the project management it would be solution B but if he wasn't it can be solution A with several clauses protecting the client from any aspect of misconduct.