Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

For Quantity Extraction , Which software is better Revit / Navisworks?

user-image
Question added by Deleted user
Date Posted: 2016/06/26
Mohammad Najjar
by Mohammad Najjar , Senior Architect / Certification Manager , Gulf Organization for Research and Development

Revit for sure. Navisworks is checking clashes between disciplines (clash detection) [beam vs. duct vs. ceiling for example).

 

Revit is optimal for quantities extraction, material takoff and schedules in general (like doors schedule).

sulthan alaudeen nazeer family
by sulthan alaudeen nazeer family , Civil Engineer-Junior , Poullaides construction

I prefer revit software for this question

Deleted user
by Deleted user

evn i am not really an expert, but i prefer Revit.

Srinivasan Rajasekaran
by Srinivasan Rajasekaran , Sr. Graphics and Design Engineer , Siemens Technology and Services Private Limited

Based on visualization, Navisworks is much more user friendly for reviewing the extracted model than revit.

If we compare in point of funtions and feature, Revit may dominate over Navisworks, because it is capable of working and editing the model with more accuracy. 

If we compare size of file, Navisworks wins the battle by producing efficient model with occuping less space file, compared to revit.

More Questions Like This