Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Why Finish to Start is the most advisable relationship to be used in Primavera P6 ?

user-image
Question added by VINOD KUMAR , Manager-Planning and PMO , Voltas Limited
Date Posted: 2016/07/02
Ahmed Makram
by Ahmed Makram , Planning and Control Engineer , Sadara Chemical Company

This is not true, there is no advisable reltionships in P6. The reltionship between activities put as per the logic sequences of work and the finish to start relationship is the most logic popular but if it is not logic it will destroy the schedule on updating.

Rameez Mannil
by Rameez Mannil , Planning Engineer , Voltas Ltd

When you begin the project, you put up the sequence of work as one ends and the next starts. This may not be true practically as you may start the successor activity once some amount of predecessor is done. So, you can't actually call it an advisable relation.

Imran Ahmed
by Imran Ahmed , Manager-Planning & Delay Analyst , Nesma United Industries (NUI) Saudi Arabia

It is common relation and close actual sequence of works in all projects.

It mainly depends on nature of activities invovlved in the project. if activities are going to start parallel nature then this relation can never be advisable. Such activities can linked by start to start and finish to finish relation with required lag to avoid open ends.

This relationship is the default relationship in the P6. It is a realtionship in which Successor starts when the predecessor ends. We can also say that when presedcessor will finish, the successor will start the next planning unit. The planning unit is defined as per user preferences and it is usually hour, day, week or month 

VINAY KUMAR GOSWAMI
by VINAY KUMAR GOSWAMI , Partner , 2MI

The underlying assumption is that you can not start the new or next activity unless the previous activity is finished. For example, you can not start laying the concrete for ceiling unless the four columns or four side walls are complete for the building. Therefore FINISH to START makes sense in thi case. However once the ground preparation is complete, you can start the construction work for all four columns (or all four side walls) simultanesously. Hence the activity of Construction of all four columns will have the relationship of START to START.

Therefore moral of the story is: There is NO DEFAULT relationship between activities. Hence it is always advisible for any shceduler or planner to work with SME (Subject Matter Expert) and Project Manager to understand the relationship bewteen activties.

Some other useful tips are:

1. Understand how your BOM code for project costing are generated.

2. What are your key project deliverables and their relationship to each other - i.e. their delivery order/ precedence/ dependence etc.

VINOD KUMAR
by VINOD KUMAR , Manager-Planning and PMO , Voltas Limited

Finish to start is most advisable relationship because of following reasons :

1. It avoids the risk of open ends in schedule.

2. Easy to find the driving path easily from finishing stage to starting stage of a project schedule.

More Questions Like This