Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Will normal overload relays trip on single phasing?

user-image
Question added by HARIPRASAD H , Project Associate , Indian Oil Corporation Limited
Date Posted: 2016/09/05
Himadri Roy
by Himadri Roy , MANAGER ELECTRICAL , STEAG ENERGY SERVICES

Yes.

Say we have 5.5 KW motor & it takes 10/11 Amps in Each Phase( Say 10.4,10.2,108 Amps in R,Y,B. We set the Over-load rleay at 10/11 Ampere.

3 Phase total current (10.4+10.2+10.8)= 31.4 Amps ----- Eq-1

If it become Single phase ( Or 2 Wire ), R-Phase got disconnected by any reason say loose Connection or Pro-long Heating. Then Y & B Phase will share 31.4 Amps ( Eq-1), So Each Phase take approx.15.7 Amps. But Overload relay set at 10-11 Amps. It will Trip the Motor in Overload.

 

HARIPRASAD H
by HARIPRASAD H , Project Associate , Indian Oil Corporation Limited

If correctly set normal overload relays will trip when motor is fully loaded due to rise in current passing through the closed supply lines but with delta connected motors patially overloaded,the rise in line current may not b sufficient to operate the overload relay and eventually one phase may become overheated

Jawad Amjad
by Jawad Amjad , Assistant Manager (O&M) , National Transmission and Despatch Company Ltd.

It should as motor will continue to run on two phases and drawing greater load which ultimately will result in tripping of motor by the overload relay.

Muahmmad Arif
by Muahmmad Arif , Operation & Maintenance / Planning Engineer , Bestway Cement

What do you means by normal overload relays mean not numerical relay ? 

Yes every relay will trip on overload if your current is more in one phase.

Juan Raphael Concepcion
by Juan Raphael Concepcion , Power Plant Maintenance Supervisor , WKSA Power Contracting Company

Yes it will trip, but takes time to trip. Because it has to produce a current which will be more than of  the setting of the overload. Thus of course will damage your motor in the long run. A delay of a second is vital in the life of a motor economically, specially on large motors.

logesh babu
by logesh babu , Senior Engineer , Titan Company Ltd

Dear sir

Over load relay can't detect the single phasing, it can detect only overload.

But during the single phasing automatically the load will increase hence indirectly it will trip.

Single phase preventer is the exact protection for single phasing issues.

Mustafa Ismail Ibrahim Mahmoud
by Mustafa Ismail Ibrahim Mahmoud , Technical Office Team Leader , GSI one of GAD industries factories 10TH OF Ramadan City. (Egypt)

Single phasing is a condition in 3-ph motors and transformers wherein the supply to one of the phases is cut off and sauses negative phase sequence voltage . Single phasing can be identified by special protective relays such as RM4 relay of Schneider.

shelesh Tiwari
by shelesh Tiwari , Manager , Havells India Limited

yes.it will trip.single phasing protection is an important feature for motor protection, they very purpose of putting a relayin circuit.

Vasile Alexandru
by Vasile Alexandru , Maintenance Electrical Engineer , Dietsmann (for BP Iraq)

Yes. A 3-phase overload relay can be installed into a single phase system making sure that all 3 sensing bi-metal elements of the relay carry the current of the load

More Questions Like This