Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

In choosing the right candidate, should the qualification weigh over attitude, or attitude weigh over the qualification?

user-image
Question added by Marvin Lomanog , Head Of HR And Administration , Dr. Klippe Philippines Corporation
Date Posted: 2016/11/01
Ali Ahmad SHRM-SCP
by Ali Ahmad SHRM-SCP , Group HR Performance Manager , FAMA Holdings Group

Qualification level of a candidate is one of the eligibility criteria which must be met by all shortlisted candidates in order to secure an interview call. Once the candidate interview starts - he get's tested for his actual knowledge, skills, aptitude and attitude. Hence, both parameters have their own importance in candidate selection!

Mohammed Azmatulla Khan
by Mohammed Azmatulla Khan , Senior Recruiter , Kbr Inc. - United Arab Emirates

Well, I Insist on hiring the candidates with right attitude over Qualification because To my opinion, it is not the degree that justifies a person but it is the person who justifies the degree. In fact, the quality of a person doesn't depend on his/her qualification. But Rather It all depends on his/her attitude towards life and willingness and desire to work to show and make the difference

Deleted user
by Deleted user

50 - 50

Example (1): A highly qualified candidate with bad attitude may harm the whole working environment, distributing negative energy to others.

Example (2): An excellent attitude candidate with less qualifications will not fit his job technically.

So, I believe that attitude & qualifications should have equal weight in the evaluation process ! 

 

P A Cariappa Appaiah
by P A Cariappa Appaiah , back office executive , Inspire Hond

" It is always", " Qualification weigh over attitude", not other way.

swati Bagga
by swati Bagga , Sr Officer HR - L&D , Times Internet

My thought on this - Weigh is equal to both education/experience and attitude. Right experience.education with right attitude is very important now a days to deal with people. As economy is focusing on globalisation and so balance is very important. Experience and attitude are not every time proportionate. Sometimes less experienced or educated person does wonders on job rather than experienced once. and sometimes people with good qualification can be pain sometimes if there attitude is not right. and so Education and attitude weigh equal for any individual.

Toufik Sahraoui
by Toufik Sahraoui , Human Resource and Recruitment Consultant , Manpower Agency

Thanks for all colleagues reply above so for me both are required to consider in selection decision when qualification answer the question know how to do the tasks in terms of the job process    

( Qualification = the knowledge ) while attitude it's about the manner we interact that knowledge with personal behaviour in workplace duties like in call center when the qualification its where the agent know the technical problems and solutions but the attitude its when the agent use his ton and influence the customer or when calming an upset customer  

Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi
by Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi , Shared Services Supervisor , Saudi Musheera Co. Ltd.

it is dependent on position and requirement and Job description

 

More Questions Like This