Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

As a general manager, do you prefer to hire young or old leaders to lead your organization and teams toward the goal? and why ?

user-image
Question added by Omar Saad Ibrahem Alhamadani , Snr. HR & Finance Officer , Sarri Zawetta Company
Date Posted: 2016/11/02
Duncan Robertson
by Duncan Robertson , Strategy Consultant , Duncan Robertson Consultancy

The only reason why you would hire an older person or a younger person is prejudice.

In the UK, for example, it is illegal to ask a candidate's age. 

Just because a certain characteristic is generally true about a certain group of people it does not mean that that characteristic applies to a particular member of that group.  For example, women tend to be less tall than men, but that does not mean that the tallest candidate will not be a a woman.  Similarly, the candidate with the most energy, enthusiasm and drive might be 60 years old.

 

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Dear Omar,

I would consider age as discrimination factor and hence age or gender No Bar, BUT these factors depend on the nature of job or business, only upon considering the scope of work or job requirements one must conclude a wise decision 

Regards

 

Ma'en AL-Rawabdeh
by Ma'en AL-Rawabdeh , General Accountant , Tornado Group

thank you for invitation

 

i don't care about age of the manger because i think the important thing is the ability and skills to manage or lead the company or team 

 

 

Toufik Sahraoui
by Toufik Sahraoui , Human Resource and Recruitment Consultant , Manpower Agency

Salam

I don't know if that applicable in ur country but consider age in hiring that mean discrimination and against labour law , all we know that some position need some maturity and seniority but we find people that are younger and much mature than older companies also want a lot of experience years  that's not meant for me any weight in term of proficiency and expertise in their field ,so a lot of have y experience but they don't carry any expertise  when you find people with3-5 y  have strong proficiency and expertise 

MOHAMMAD MAHMOUD HASAN AL-HASHASH
by MOHAMMAD MAHMOUD HASAN AL-HASHASH , مدير صيانه , شركة الاستراتيجي للتجاره

dear 

The ability and skills to work and the right to lead the management team and sophistication comapny is the important thing in the work I do not care about the age 

 

regards

jasmina malnar
by jasmina malnar , Head of Marketing and Indirect Procurement , Hrvatski telekom

Age makes no difference for a leader. It may make a difference for a manager, but even then, one has to balance energy (young) with experience (old).

Wail Zayid
by Wail Zayid , Facilities Supervisor , Shade Corporation

Thank u for the invitation.

I believe it depends on the job required and the goals needed to take the company to a hire level, some jobs required old for experience some jobs require young with prospects ideas   

DR MD ANWAR HOSSAIN
by DR MD ANWAR HOSSAIN , Moderator , bayt.com

Thank you for invitation & posting a good question. I agreed with honorable colleagues Mr.Duncan RobertsonRajiv KohliToufik SahraouiMa`en AL-Rawabdeh.

Deleted user
by Deleted user

thank you for invitation

 

 I agreed with reply Mr.Duncan Robertson, Rajiv Kohli, Toufik Sahraoui, Ma`en AL-Rawabdeh.

 

 

 

Juhi Dubey
by Juhi Dubey , Freelance Photographer , Freelance

A Leader is always a person with potential and a right mix of apt qualities which can never be judged based on the gender or age. According to me, for the right candidate, age does not matter at all.

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Of course I would hire young leaders , As it always branching out iin lot of factors and you have to compare it :

 

Young: 

  1. New methods of leading and operations.
  2. changing company structure would help the employees to be more productive
  3. cutting costs would be efficient in growing in other fields would develop the company product and services.

Old :

  1. Predictable methods of management would be easy to caught by competitors.
  2. high costs because of the experience, which would be an advantage in some areas of business .

To summaries it , It would be very hard to choose but i prefer the young people to lead because they want to prove them selves rather than someone who improved him/her self in a company he worked in a long time ago.

More Questions Like This