Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Who do you think is in charge of the literary work: the author and creator or the reader and critic? Why?

user-image
Question added by Dina Khatib , Brand and Communications Manager , Bayt.com
Date Posted: 2016/11/10
مها شرف
by مها شرف , معلمة لغة عربية , وزارة التربية السورية

I agree with M's Fiona Rustom Jagose's answer. Thanks for the invitation. 

Fiona Rustom Jagose
by Fiona Rustom Jagose , teacher trainee , Wellington College

It very much depends on which literary work you are referring to, in which time and preceding which notable event or events. Also one must factor in how literate a society is in all socio-economic brackets, as well as gender, class and racial groups'  freedom to be published and whether literature is considered normal or oven permitted in that society.

 As a case in point in the last Man Booker prize winner, Eleanor Catton, was from a country; Aotearoa / New Zealand where the ratio of literature reading surpasses that of any other. She would not have been in charge of her success due to the intense competition of various other high caliber writers who had been equally and freely exposed to a wide range of literature. Had she been born years earlier she may well have been banned from writing any literature at all.

In terms of English literature we see that the ex-British colonies had the English language imposed on them as well as almost rote teaching of several classics of the time. The term of 'the English novel' was reduced to 'the novel' in part due to some embarrassment from England that the colonised outperformed the literature writers from England. Today we can see that India dominates the high literature scene.

 

So, given that there is no 'the' per sae to literary work in general " Who do you think is in charge of the literary work?" remains a loaded question.

 

 

More Questions Like This