Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Is it part of your responsibility as an HR manager to solve conflict between two employees or should their direct managers solve the conflict?

user-image
Question added by Zain Khater , Project Supervisor – StartUp Project , Injaz
Date Posted: 2016/12/23
Omar Saad Ibrahem Alhamadani
by Omar Saad Ibrahem Alhamadani , Snr. HR & Finance Officer , Sarri Zawetta Company

Thanks 

Yes, HR should be a part of any conflict solving beside management or direct manager, since the mentioned department. Is responsible for such aspects and issues which will evaluation and general performance based on it for each employee 

 

Md Fazlur Rahman
by Md Fazlur Rahman , Procurement Specialist , Engineering and Planning Consultants Ltd

The HR Manager and the Direct Manager shall sit jointly with the two employees who are in conflict. This is more easy approach and  the problem could be solved quickly.

Ali Ahmad SHRM-SCP
by Ali Ahmad SHRM-SCP , Group HR Performance Manager , FAMA Holdings Group

The primary level of conflict resolution is with the Line Manager. If the issue is still unresolved, it has to be escalated to HR Disciplinary Committee which will conduct a formal inquiry, investigate the issue and ensure a positive closure to the conflict!

Hisham Regal
by Hisham Regal , Regional Assistant , TASFD, DANIDA, TA to SFD, Carlbro

The answer  will be as  the followings :-

Their direct line manager should  solve the conflict  at  first . within limited time for example one month . 

After one month for example the HR should check and see is it solved or not. if not 

Then the HR should raise up the problem to the top management to solve it .

I also would like to add its depends on the  role of company HR manual 

lima Abdul Haq
by lima Abdul Haq , Self Study , Self Study

The Direct Manager should have the skills of Leadership, problem solving and works as an HR as well, as the modern HR focuses on giving HR responsibilities for each person called (Manager), and by this, each manager should have the ability to solve his employees' conflict, by end, if solving the conflict reached a point which is unable to be solved by the Manager alone, this has to go to the Department Head of the employees, and if still wasn't solved this then can be discussed by the Direct Manager, Department Head and the HR to be solved together!

Abid Hussain
by Abid Hussain , HR Officer , ETIMAD HOLDING

HR professional must resolve employee issue and conflict as this must be their top priority which at end will reflect in both employee and company growth .   

Qais Akash
by Qais Akash , IT Business Partner , IT solutions

It depends on the conflict, if it is related to Human Capital Department, it is ok for the HR Manager to solve it, if the conflict is about sales, the same , it is OK for the sales manager to try to solve this conflict, each Manager needs to help the employees to solve any conflict as the company achieves its goals by the collaboration of all the managers and employees together.  

Akhter Gul
by Akhter Gul , HR Specialist. , BACH

I would highly suggest the amicable resolution by the direct manager, without going into long procedures.lets make sure not to be biased or it will leave a direct negative impact on the staff as well as on indirect impact on rest of the existing members too.

In case it needs acceleration then Direct manager shall submit in written what's the issue and the factors responsible for it and the solution he advises. 

HR should speak to concerned employees in separate and try to resolve it amicably with proper counselling (Laws & Company Policies as well as human touch). HR should prepare a corrective action and counselling which the concerned staff, direct & HR Manager should sign and keep originals in staff's file and give the staff copies.

If the issue still exists, then HR should raise it to the disciplinary committee which is either chaired by HR or HR is part of it and proper investigation should be done, concerned employees should be questioned by committee and according to the findings, action should be taken as per the prevailing Laws & Company Policies. No leniency should be shown here and justified action should be taken.

Ahmed Ibrahim
by Ahmed Ibrahim , Veterinarian , Ministry of Agriculture

Direct managers are better placed to resolve conflicts that arise between employees because the direct manager is more in contact with the employees that he manages than the HR manager. Ideally the line manager should have the skills and leadership qualities that enable him to solve such conflicts and maintain an environment that is conducive to good work performance.

Amer Mamo
by Amer Mamo , Office Manager , 4u4ever

HR and direct manager cooperate to find a solution. 

Doris Carreon
by Doris Carreon , Senior Retail Operations Manager , RSH Middle East LLC

Conflict between two employees  should be resolved first by the direct managers as they have direct line responsibility over the behaviour of their staff.  In the event that the direct managers are unable to resolve the issue at their level, then the case gets raised up to the HR Manager's level.

More Questions Like This