Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

For large-scale energy production, which is the most suitable? Photovoltaics or Solar Thermal Power Plants?

user-image
Question added by Abdeljalil CHEGDALI , Electrical Engineer , EMAC Engineering Office
Date Posted: 2017/04/01
ABHISHEK GAUTAM
by ABHISHEK GAUTAM , Engineer , ntpc

Talking int he terms of Efficiency ,for large scale energy production we can use CSP i.e: Concentrated Solar Power for more efficiency.

Although PV have lower efficiency.

Bobbysance Paremal
by Bobbysance Paremal , Service Head , Bharat Benz

Solar thermal power plants are more effective, unlimited source of energy from the sun and no Solar thermal power generation systems collect and concentrate sunlight to produce the high-temperature heat needed to generate electricity and the photovoltaic cell, commonly called a solar cell, is a non-mechanical device that converts sunlight directly into electricity. Some PV cells can convert artificial light into electricity and the cost of manufacturing PV Cells are much higher, In that way, solar thermal power plants are more effective.

anas alkeaid
by anas alkeaid , Strategy and Projects Director , ADAL

Thermal power plants are more efficient during the night time, but it is more complicated systems to build comparing with pv system

Nanang Purwantoro
by Nanang Purwantoro , BID LEADER for Utility , Enertelindo Kencana

Thank you for invitation, I Though Solar thermal power plant is most suitable for large-scale energy production.

Fikret Sehovic
by Fikret Sehovic , Estimator and Inside Technical Support , ADE-Systetems,Inc.

Thermal Power Plants would be the most suitable for large-scale energy production.

You need to keep in mind what type of fuel you have at your disposal, coal, gas, oil, and take into account transportation costs and other costs, warehousing, and the like.

If the thermal power plant's location were in the area where there is enough sunshine days (solar energy is available), economic analysis should be carried out in each case, taking all available factors into account (construction costs, guided plant, maintenance, etc.) and due to ecological factors one would also consider this solution.

But in any case the first choice would be a thermal power plant because it is about the production of a large amount of energy. This means thermal power plants 100,200,500 and more MW.

Jeffy Johnson Johnson
by Jeffy Johnson Johnson , Asst.Manager , Windforce Management Services

Depends purely on the natural resource potential of the geographic in question. 

Ismail Ali al-Maziji
by Ismail Ali al-Maziji , Systems Engineer electronic and industrial. , Maziji Systems Engineering (MSE)

PV cells are growing rapidly, from a small base to a global capacity of 46400 MW at the end of 2011 representing 0.5% of the world's electricity demand 5 More than 100 countries are using photovoltaic solar power.

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Here the answer is logical. Both the generation systems Solar and Thermal has their own advantages and disadvantages. Still many countries in the world are dependent on the traditional energy generation systems. 

In terms of reliability if we talk Thermal is very suitable for large scale generation, but the coal reserves and co2 emission matters a lot.

The Solar though initial investment cost is high, can assure the operation up to long times with low running costs. But intermittent in nature so cannot be reliable.

Stephen Lubrano
by Stephen Lubrano , Vice Chairman & CEO , Alternative Energy Solutions

Solar thermal would be the best choice.

adel arbane
by adel arbane , conseiller technique , GIZ

solar thermal power plants

amr salah
by amr salah , ALMNABR CONSULTANT ENGINEERING OFFICE

solar energy power plant .... but still need reserches and developments 

More Questions Like This