Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What is the advantages and disadvantages of a PFR?

user-image
Question added by Mohamed Karem Mahmoud , HSE Deputy lead , APMT
Date Posted: 2017/05/01
Muhammad Anas
by Muhammad Anas , Process Engineer , Pakistan Petroleum Limited

PFR are continous type of reactors with high conversion rates, compact in design, opex is less however, temperature in such reactors are controlled critically, which makes temperature control difficult.

Sajad Rather
by Sajad Rather , Business Development Manager – UAE & KSA , Trans-Asia Pipeline Services

Continuous operation, high conversion rate, less cost for operation.

Tempratures are hard to control .

 

Suriabashani Padayachee
by Suriabashani Padayachee , Head of Department of Maths and Science , Buffelsdale Secondary School

PFR have a high volumetric unit conversion, run for long periods of time without maintainable, and the the heat transfer rate can be optimized by using thinner tubes or fewer thicker tubes in parallel.

Disadvantage of PFR are that temperatures are hard to control and can result in undesirable temperature gradients.

Hatim Elamin AbdEllatief Abdedaem
by Hatim Elamin AbdEllatief Abdedaem , DIrector of industry adminstration at Gezira state , ministry of finance and economic affairs Gezira state

Advantages: Continuous operation, high conversion rate, less cost for operation. Disadvantages: temperature gradients, high maintenance cost       

CSTRs (Continuous Stirred Tank Reactor) and PFRs have fundamentally different equations, so the kinetics of the reaction being undertaken will to some extent determine which system should be used. However there are a few general comments that can be made with regards to PFRs compared to other reactor types.

Plug flow reactors have a high volumetric unit conversion, run for long periods of time without maintenance, and the heat transfer rate can be optimized by using more, thinner tubes or fewer, thicker tubes in parallel. Disadvantages of plug flow reactors are that temperatures are hard to control and can result in undesirable temperature gradients. PFR maintenance is also more expensive than CSTR maintenance.

Through a recycle loop a PFR is able to approximate a CSTR in operation. This occurs due to a decrease in the concentration change due to the smaller fraction of the flow determined by the feed; in the limiting case of total recycling, infinite recycle ratio, the PFR perfectly mimics a CSTR.

l

 

More Questions Like This