Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What are the good and the bad things about group interviews?

user-image
Question added by Alia Hassan , Head of Human Resources , Al Hurreyah for consulting
Date Posted: 2019/06/16
saleem abrar
by saleem abrar , Recruitment Coordinator (Client Management & Recruitment) , HABSONS JOBUPS LIMITED

Group interview should be conducted when large volume of interviewers are there. It should be avoided as many interviewers could not perform well and cat express their views and campany may loose poitential employee.

Rajani Patel
by Rajani Patel , Senior Manager , SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd

In group interviews the beat part is we find out how participants react to views and how sharp they are to catch the right question and respond to it. We also get to know how comfortable participants are in public speaking and their conflict management skills. The major problems in group discussion is that HR May miss on identifying the intelligent employees who are more thinkers than executors. Thinkers generally do not speak at the drop of a hat and the proportion of thinkers vs executors are very important to have in any organisation. Not all may be good at public speaking but may be very skilled and good at their jobs. These people will get missed out.

Ali Yakub Seesi Rutherfod
by Ali Yakub Seesi Rutherfod , Deputy DIRECTOR of Education , Head of Department of Social Science , St. Jerome Snr High School

Thanks for the question my name sake. Group interviews helps to easily get the best among candidates. It is also not time consuming. Some of the bad things about it are that a shy person may not do well in a group but might be the best on individual interview. Also a candidate who is an introvert may not do well in this type of interview

Amjid Noor
by Amjid Noor , Admin Director , CS Limousine

Pro's of group interviews are you get detail information about the candidate. One can judge the potential behavior, responsiveness, qualities, expression and team work of the candidate and how he may react in the crowd with experiences, ideas, problem solutions, leadership qualities. Con's of group interview are when you are hiring an employee for a particular task like back office work, data punching, accounts etc that doesn't involve much of people interaction or public meetings, visits than it will not be much effective. That mostly require detail discussion about the skill, knowledge and expertise. So there is a chance that confidence may steal the show in group interview where as there might be a prospect/candidate who will be expert in the work but will be shy or less expressive in front of the panel or group and could be missed. So they both have there pro's and con's !.

Rania Bannan
by Rania Bannan , senior sales officer , Sharjah Islamic Bank

If employment interviews may affect others' opinions and make the committee react negatively to their morale, there are positive points, namely learning from the opposite view of some

 

More Questions Like This