Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

In a company, internal audit is asked to report to Accounts Manager.What will be the consequence?

user-image
Question added by mukkur srinivasan varadhan , Chartered Accountant , Chartered Accountant in practice
Date Posted: 2013/12/29
Rehan Qureshi
by Rehan Qureshi , Financial Consultant , Self Employeed

This is not fair, Internal Auditor must not report to accounting manager at all. 

hazeel zafar
by hazeel zafar , Senior Functional Consultant , A-Solutions DMCC

Objectivity of internal auditor would be impaired. His work performance & decisions would be biased which is against codes of professional ethics.

Shahzad Khan
by Shahzad Khan , Deputy Manager - Human Resources , The Searle Company Limited

Then the Accounts manager will be requesting the divisional heads to fulfill their requirement to end this audit process....

Nahaz Kunnummal
by Nahaz Kunnummal , Internal Auditor , Almeera Consumer Goods

Internal Auditor may discuss the concerned issues with the Accounts manager of Financial controller. But normally the internal audit report is issued to the the audit committee  and then to the concerned HOD's for corrective actions.

Ahmed Saeed
by Ahmed Saeed , Supply Chain and Purchasing Manager , Tuff Gear Ltd.

This should not even happen in the first place, and it is a big NO! 

If this happens their will be a potential conflict of interest.

If he reports to the accounts manager, he wont be able to examine the company's books with an objective eye. The reason being that the person ultimately responsible for the books, the accounts manager, will be the internal auditor's boss. 

 

Khalid Noor
by Khalid Noor , Accounting Manager , FedEx

In a small Company if the accounts manager oversee most of the functions of the board then its ok. In large companies IA have direct access to CEO and Audit comitte constituted by the board. If in large company IA reports to Account. manager then his independecne is questionable.

TAHIR KHALIL  CFO FINANCE MANAGER  ADVERTISING  CONTRACTING   REAL ESTATE   PRODUCTION   TELECOM
by TAHIR KHALIL CFO FINANCE MANAGER ADVERTISING CONTRACTING REAL ESTATE PRODUCTION TELECOM , FINANCIAL & OPERATIONS MANAGER , Brand Options Advertising LLC / Prodaction creative Advertising LLC

If Internal auditor is reporting to Accounts Manager, purpose of the Internal will be lost. By the why,  who is sugeesting to Board to appoint IA. if there is only Manager Accounts in that company.

Its not possible for internal audit to report to accounts Manager. Becuase, accounts Manager rule is like a mediator between end user (executor) and audit personnel accordingly. Inter audt personnel can acquire the record from accounts Manager where and when required. Even some time accounts Manager report to internal audit.

More Questions Like This