Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

which one of these persons has better chance to find a new job? focused in one indusrty or experience in many industries?

let us assume two people have the same level of experience and education. one with focused and deep in one industry and the other with broad experience in different industries. which one of these people is in a better situation to find a new job?

user-image
Question added by Akbar Bakhshmand , Production / Business Analysis , Saipa Corp
Date Posted: 2013/06/15
JAIME ESTRADA
by JAIME ESTRADA , Contracts Engineer (Contracts Management) , SRACO-SATORP

A person who has broad experience in different industries is in a better position to find a new job faster - as he has more job opportunities suitable to his varied experience, but there is a probability that he can not get a high salary that he desires.

 

On the other hand, a person who has been focused in one industry can find a new job longer but most likely, he will be offered a high salary that he desires because Employers prefer a person who has been focused for long years in a specific industry as he is perceived to be expert in that industry.

Khaled Abdelrehim ACCA DipIFR CMA
by Khaled Abdelrehim ACCA DipIFR CMA , Financial Analysis Assistant General Manager , Khalda Petroleum Company

The first focused person will find the job he wnats with better remuniration but in longer time, the second will find a job faster.

Mohammad Tohamy Hussein Hussein
by Mohammad Tohamy Hussein Hussein , Chief Executive Officer & ERP Architect , Egyptian Software Group

I see that persons with good experiences in more than an industry (within his/her profession) stand a better chance of getting a job.

Vidya Baday
by Vidya Baday , Chief Operating Officer , Intone Networks

Its better to have more exposure to different environments, industries, expertises so one can develop better skills and perspective at work; also applies to even general in life.

Having expertise in one field is good; but also limiting oneself to that trade or skill; with the present world and changing technologies on day to day basis its going to be tougher in the end.

anayat bukhari
by anayat bukhari , Researcher, English Content Writer, Publisher , Noor Foundation

It is a bit tricky question but we can create two scenarios to answer it in a better way.

1. A person having experience in a single industry is considered better than one who have a record of experience in more than one industries.

2. A person having experience in many co-related industries has a better chance to be selected than a person with only single industry experience.

 

So the difference is of multi industry experience in quite opposite or irrelavant industries and multi industry experience in co-related industries.

Gautam Anand
by Gautam Anand , Manager - Human Resource, Training and Quality Assurance , SAVY Hospitality & Real Estate

One who has a set goal and knows how to attain it.

 

Thank you.

Aftab Ahmed
by Aftab Ahmed , Senior Engineer- Technical Service and Coordination Department , Pakistan Oilfields Ltd (POL)

I some cases Multi-experience is a Negative Point in CV Like a Medical Sales Representative must not claim in his CVs that he may look after all type of Engineering Sales also.

 

While in some cases, Multi-Experience is a Positve Point in CV like a Mechnical Engineer may have also somewhat Electrical / Instrumentation & Civil Engineering Experience also.

Further same Engineer may have worked for Different Industries like Chemical, Power, Textile etc.

Saiful Islam Hiron
by Saiful Islam Hiron , Site HR Manager , Handicap International

It depends on two things:

1. Functional need

2. Strategic need

If any position need functional work, he/she has more chance for getting job in single industry because functional position needs relevant experience. If any position needs strategic work , he/she has more chance for getting job in group industries.

Chris Papanikolaou
by Chris Papanikolaou , Executive manager , FIREWOOD-ENERGY PELLET SA

In one field you can be expert,in more than one you can be good to a lot of them you can be confused,,,,,,,,,,,,

zafar abbas minhas
by zafar abbas minhas , Freelance Writer , DAILY MASHRAQ

better to have one industry but in case of management it does not apply.

GUL NAY
by GUL NAY , General Manager , Emirate China Commercial Centre LLC

I beleive the person should have more chances to get the job who worked for mulitpal companies. Because he have had exposure to different industries. And when some one work for so many companies he makes mistakes and it is saying that you learn from your  mistakes, on the other hand a person have experience in the same field he get used to that sector and he can not make any progress to the company. 

More Questions Like This