Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Internal Audit and external audit are complementary.Is the statement right?

user-image
Question added by mukkur srinivasan varadhan , Chartered Accountant , Chartered Accountant in practice
Date Posted: 2014/05/02
HELAL Al Shadidi
by HELAL Al Shadidi , Internal Audit Supervisor , Combined Group Contracting Co. (K.S.C.P)

IIA Standard1300 covers the Quality Assurance and Improvement Program that need to be established by the CAE covering all aspects of the internal audit activity. Standard1312 requires that "External Assessment must be conducted at least once every five years by a qualified,independent assessor or assessment team from outside the organization.

Kamran Anjum
by Kamran Anjum , Head of Internal Audit , Rafhan Maize Products Company limited, Faisalabad, Pakistan, Ingredion Incorporated Gmbh

As functions and requirements both are different. But ways and means of acheiving the objectives are almost same. So we can say that they complement each other in terms of their functioning but not in terms of their objectives.

Hossam Eldin Saad Fesseekh Fesseekh
by Hossam Eldin Saad Fesseekh Fesseekh , Financial Manager , Teba Development Industries

Internal Audit objective is audit all financial actions and process , reporting to CFO . On the other hand External audit objective is audit all financial statements with sample of actions , analysis the final outputs reporting the shareholders.

As long as Internal auditor do his job with the standers it help the External to moving fast in reports and statements ,  Yes Internal and External are complementary.

Abdul Mannan
by Abdul Mannan , Senior Consultant SAP Business One , Tyconz Information Technology

NO

Raghavender shivva
by Raghavender shivva , Chartered Accountant , Chartered Accountants Firm

No 

Adnan Ul Haq FCCA
by Adnan Ul Haq FCCA , Finance / Operations Officer , Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations

Internal auditing is an independent activity within Organization designed to add value and improve an organization's operations. It helps an organization to evaluate and improve the effectiveness of risk management, control, and governance processes. Internal auditing helps organization to achieve it's objective by providing insight and recommendations based on analyses and assessments of data and business processes. Whereas external audit performs an audit in accordance with specific laws or rules on the financial statements of entity and their main objective is give opinion on financial statements whether it gives true and fair information about entity financials. External Auditor usually report to the investors, government agencies, and the general public.

 

Both functions have their own importance, internal auditors are more focused on company operations, risk management control and governance whereas external auditors are focused on financial statement whether it gives true and fair reflection of the company’s financial position

 

Muhammad Usman Ashraf
by Muhammad Usman Ashraf , VAT Accountant , Jumeirah Golf Estates

Although these are two distinct functions but they do have some complimentary characteristics

Mohammad Saadeh
by Mohammad Saadeh , مدقق داخلي رئيسي , شركة ناشونال

There is a difference between them as the internal audit depends on the internal control systems and modify aphid to serve the facility and the research sample it wider or all data movements and the administrative and financial procedures , The external audit depends on the samples and the extent of the commitment established the terms of internal control and the strength of the internal audit control of the facility and extracted the results of the financial position of the entity

 

 

Mubashir Shahzad
by Mubashir Shahzad , Oracle Functional Consultant/ERP Business Analyst , Jaffer Business System

yes right, if the scope, objectivity and independance of internal audit is sufficient and appropriate then relaince can be put upon by external audit. 

Raza Khan
by Raza Khan , Assistant Manager Internal Audit , Rehman Medical Institute (Private) Limited

I would differ to the statement. Complimentary are the activities whose objectives can not be acheived by doing both of them. External and Internal Audit are different functions both are designed to add value, External Audit add value primarily to the decissions of General Public and regulatory bodies While Internal Auditors Add value to the buisness of which they are acting as an important function by doing objective assurance and consulting activity Independently.

Alfatih Alaalim Elzubair Gaidoum Naway
by Alfatih Alaalim Elzubair Gaidoum Naway , Group Internal Auditor , FAZAH Industrial Company

While internal auditor provide appropriate assurance to entity management about the compliancy of the transactions with policy and procedures that aproved by directorate management ..external auditor serves other parties and wide ranges of interesting people. .and governmental corporations

More Questions Like This