Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

REQUEST forFEEDBACK: what is your view on Specialty Answers "copy-pasted" from the web? Should they be voted up?

A. Yes, I don’t mind at all. B. Yes, I don’t mind if they're useful. C. Yes, not everybody has the skill to write own answers. D. Yes, I don’t mind if they're personalized & edited. E. Yes, only if they contain a link to original source. F. No, it's just plagiarism even if useful. G. No, it is unfair to others & to the specialty rating system. H. No, they should not be voted up or down BUT ignored. I. No, they should not be voted up BUT down. J. Other: …….

user-image
Question added by Khatim Abbas Seed , BUSINESS CONSULTANT , Google
Date Posted: 2014/05/04
Fida Abo Alrob
by Fida Abo Alrob , Sr. Copywriter , Imena Digital

I vote for H "Yes, only if they contain a link to original source."

Divyesh Patel
by Divyesh Patel , Assistant Professional Officer- Treasury , City Of Cape Town

C. Yes, not everybody has the skill to write own answers.

D - This is a sharing platform and we are all here   to learn

Imran Rasheed
by Imran Rasheed , Regional Sales Developer, Eastern, Jouf and Northern border provinces , HALA Payment Solutions.

J. If you intend to answer, share your experience and guide the person in positive way. Anyone who is using Bayt.com can google it by himself well if he/she needs to find only "The Correct Answer".

Maalik Muhamed
by Maalik Muhamed , Deputy Mill Manager , AZANIA GROUP OF COMPANYS

well i think some questions or specialty need correct answer for example database codes so copying from w3school will be ok.

E. Yes, only if they contain a link to original source

HARIKRISHNAN R
by HARIKRISHNAN R , Principal Mechanical Engineer , Methode Electronics, Inc.

B . The pupose getting served. All they need was some answers.

Khatim Abbas Seed
by Khatim Abbas Seed , BUSINESS CONSULTANT , Google

My own choices in order of preference are:

 

D. Yes, I don’t mind if they're personalized & edited. (Preferably while placing a link still) E. Yes, only if they contain a link to original source.

 

Most of us must've gone through the tedious yet challenging experience of academic writing, when writing our (oh so important) thesis that got us our titles. One basic international component of such papers is "correct referencing", aimed at early-age consolidation of respect for intellectual property and encouragement of genuine addition to science& research. We are not practicing science around here, but we do practice (online) research one way or another. It is only a testimony of our deeply-rooted professional excellence to hold on to our attained college skills and principles of proper knowledge attainment & sharing.

 

 

Small remark: any too lengthy, obviously100% copy-pasted answer from the web in haste, without even being read by the poster, is mostly totally ignored by me, albeit for having to scroll down so much to read other more personal answers. It can be sufficient to place a link in such case, without cluttering the page, using up too much space or slowing down its loading time.   

Deleted user
by Deleted user

I would answer J. (other), if you are quoting something that you believe in yourself but it is phrased differently, why not use it, saves writing it twice or repeating yourself! However to my mind it has to be almost word for word how you would express it yourself or it undoubtedbly becomes plagarism, I believe very much in expressing yourself without recourse to using another's "words", there have been many examples on this forum of people whose english might not have been strictly correct, but what they have done is used their own words and "expressed" themselves in exemplary fashion, these are people I admire.

SMARAGDI FILIPPAKOPOULOU
by SMARAGDI FILIPPAKOPOULOU , Secretary , Public sector (temporary job)

I don't mind if they are originated from another source, because after all we don't know everything. As long as this point of view is expressing the person's beliefs, is ok. So my answer is D+E.

almera matus
by almera matus , Facilities Management Bid And Tender Estimator , Tectron

ANSWER IS E.

safeer andarath
by safeer andarath , IT Specialist , Ferrari World, Yas WaterWorld & Warner Bros. World Abu Dhabi

A big

Note:searching in google for a creative answer is also a skill.

More Questions Like This