Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Which one of the following is the best model for marketing and sales: Having one marketing manager and one sales manager or a commercial manager?

user-image
Question added by Ahmed Fathy Abdel Mawla Abdel Maksoud , Sales & Distribution Supervisor , Abdullah Al Mujahid For Trade and Distribution, Saudi Arabia
Date Posted: 2013/08/17
Deleted user
by Deleted user

A commercial manager is a sales-minded person in reality . Having a commercial manager may be the right choice in a "sales-minded company" but a commercial manager  does not have the genuine marketing and brand management skills set most of the time . In today's world a sales minded company can't survive very long time . So in my opinion it's better to have separate managers for marketing and sales departments . These two managers should better report to different directors and the major contribution for a company with long term objectives is to have also a CMO. ( Chief Marketing Officer ) in the organization . 

Mohammad Ahmed
by Mohammad Ahmed , External Auditor , Crowe Soltions

There should be a segregation between the sales marketing but they should report to one head. A clear job description for both is a must and very vital to mitigate the conflict.

Ammar Shami MSc  CSE CME PMP
by Ammar Shami MSc CSE CME PMP , Business Development Director MENA , Boskalis

The commercial manager is an old title that was used by the British and some industrial companies. The commercial manager combine , sales, marketing and supply chain in one title. 

This could generate a conflict of interest as the same manager is buying and selling the same products purchased by himself. 

If you are service oriented and customer centric you will not have a commercial management title. 

Most organizations that have commercial management they have a production or technical process. If the company want to have an independent business department for sales and marketing to better serve the client then commercial management will be only for the supply chain. 

the organization need to shift from commercial manager position to CMO position to allow more focus on customers and provide better services. This depends in the readiness and transformational strategy of the organization and how it plan its growth. 

Ahmed Farag
by Ahmed Farag , General Manager , Rubikans

marketing manager and sales manager but to be reported to same director

 

Virendra Singh
by Virendra Singh , India Representative/ Consultant , MM ONE GROUP SRL (Italy) BOOKING ONE

Depend on the infrastructure of the organisation. SME can have only one Marketing & Sales Manager and big organisation can have2 heads separetely.

Deleted user
by Deleted user

Having one marketing manager and a sales manager

zafar abbas minhas
by zafar abbas minhas , Freelance Writer , DAILY MASHRAQ

DEPENDS ON THE COMPANY SIZE, NATURE OF MARKET AND COMPETITION...............

More Questions Like This