Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

Which of the following its better for 3D design for architecture: 1) ArchiCad 2) Artlantis 3) 3Ds Max 4) AutoCad?

user-image
Question ajoutée par Muhamed Beqiri , Architect , Private
Date de publication: 2015/07/23
Utilisateur supprimé
par Utilisateur supprimé

Autocad is the basic software to design and you need extra tool for animation and rendering techniques.

Dejan Petrovic
par Dejan Petrovic , Director , virtualarchitecture d.o.o.

For architect most rapid way of visualization is archicad with rendering in artlantis. Generally the answer is "I'm using this software ... because I can  adjusted it toward my needs"    

3D rendering has become an invaluable tool for architects, designers, and artists to bring their visions to life. With photorealistic3D renders, you can showcase building designs, product concepts, or any creation in an immersive way before construction even begins. I recently discovered3dastudio and was impressed by their Architectural visualization services. Their portfolio includes stunning exterior and interior renderings that capture light, textures, and details beautifully. Last year, a friend was designing a new retail space and3Dastudio created renderings that helped him win over investors. Their team really brought his ideas to life. For any project where you want to visualize possibilities, I'd recommend checking out their website. Their artistry can make concepts feel tangible.

USAMA YOSSRY AHMED GENDIA
par USAMA YOSSRY AHMED GENDIA , Resident Engineer , ACE ARAB CONSULANT ENGINEER - MOHARM BAKHOOM

Rhino is like that comically sized Swiss Army knife... Easy to use with lots of tools you'd recognize but probably a ton that you're like "what the hell would I ever use this for?"

3DS Max is like a fighter jet.... Immensely powerful and fast but it's so damn complicated to use that few people ever truly master it. However in the right hands it's hard to beat.

Sketchup is basically like Lego. Given the average person you can make some stuff very quickly and easily but chances are it's not going to be complex. Some people who have immersed themselves heavily in to it can do some pretty impressive stuff but it's very time consuming.

For rendering, Lumion is like playing the sims. It's about as simple you can get, real time with assets. Not super realistic but definitely expressive and easy to use.

VRay is like kerbal space program. Basically if you follow instructions you can get some nice stuff working but to really succeed with it you need to learn it inside out and really start experimenting

 

Sketchup is like all of these programs but without any of the functionality or ability to handle and process larger files. Rhino is a nurbs based modeling program great for landscapes and sweeping curves, used by industrial designers as well as landscape architects Grasshopper is a generative / algorithmic design plug in for Rhino V-Ray is a rendering engine that has a great ability to handle light

I've never used Lumion or3DS Max, although I hear they are all good programs

The question is not "which one is best" but, unfortunately, "which one do I need" ... What are you doing in your office or school program? What aspects of3d modeling interest you?

For instance, if you wanted to do digital fabrication I would tell you to stick with rhino for its ability to model intricate surfaces, as well as its integration with grasshopper and the ability to export in ONE MILLION file formats. This one is my personal favorite because I believe it has the ability to create more nuanced geometry and just generally handles the scale of my work better. I work with a lot of TIN surfaces of entire regions in my practice of landscape architecture.

Stay away from MAYA as it will likely not be as practical or functional as you would need it to be (you didn't mention it, I just thought I would add that). MAYA is great for animators and3D character/object modeling, but not so great at spatial design.

VRay can handle most of your rendering needs and is compatible (although expensive) with a lot of programs.

If you told me that you wanted to do more than just make simple shapes I would tell you that ANYTHING would be better suited (and worth the effort to learn) than sketchup. Be proficient in sketchup because, unfortunately, most small firms do not have the resources to buy complicated and expensive software suites ... do NOT make it the only3D program you can operate.

My personal opinion is that we, as a profession (I'm a L.ARCH) need to stop perpetuating the use of Sketchup. That's all I can say without getting on a soap box. If you like3D modeling do yourself a favor and invest the time learning something more substantial

 

 

yasser bakdash
par yasser bakdash , مدير , projects managment

MOST COMMON3DS MAX

WITH AUTO CAD

Khadar shameer pullolil
par Khadar shameer pullolil , Motion graphic designer , Omega Cinefx (Qatar Division)

Defenitly 3d Max,

The Procedural Modifieres allow you to  alter any time during  design.  Many changes will happen always during design stage of any architectural Project.

So I preffer 3d max for Architectural Visualization.

Utilisateur supprimé
par Utilisateur supprimé

I would prefer3D Max, It gives you better control :)

عبدالله الخابور
par عبدالله الخابور , مهندس معماري/ Architect/mimar/ , EMİRŞAH YAPI DENETİM LTD . ŞTİ

3Ds MaxThis is the best and most realistic program

 

More Questions Like This