Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

In waste water system which of the traps are preffer in application either p-traps or s-traps?

user-image
Question ajoutée par mohamedi kassim hassan kaila , Mechanical Engineer -Plumbing and Hvac designer , Mes Engineering Consultancy Ltd
Date de publication: 2015/08/13
Muhammad Arsalan Siddiqui
par Muhammad Arsalan Siddiqui , Associate Director (MEP) , JLL

p Traps are preferred but S can also be used

Arshad Sultan
par Arshad Sultan , Head of Department (Plumbing & Fire Fighting System) , City Diamond Contracting LLC, Dubai, UAE

Normally in plumbing system P trap is most common trap. Which is provided in waste line prior to enter the sewage network and for the equipment drain like HVAC,Bidet ,shower etc. S trap can be find in WC & this kind of selection depends on the interior or architect choice. Function for the both is same ,used to trap the foul smell only.

Sravan Kumar Saradhi
par Sravan Kumar Saradhi , MEP Coordination , MAPCO

P-traps are preffered for drainage line. The main purpose of this is to create a water pocket that will stop any foul smell from entering the building.

S-traps are only concerned with the WC's type being used, after approval from Architects. Depedning on if the drainage line is connected through floor or through wall.

Randy Frias
par Randy Frias , Driver/Warehouse Assistant , Robinsons Land Corporation

p-traps, it is easily to trouble shoot when have clogged.

gregorio sillana aldamia
par gregorio sillana aldamia , Plumber Technician , Al Qussie International Contracting Company

in water system I prefer in application in p-traps because the water was very convenient when p-traps was use.

benjackson ndirangu warui
par benjackson ndirangu warui , Plumber , United aryan

P traps are best why these hepls the water closet flow of waste water to move smoothly and gently avoid ing so many corner's

The 'P' trap - normally these have a screw joint half way along so that:

  • For installation, the outlet can be moved through about 270° in the horizontal plane so that it will mate with a horizontal waste pipe coming in from an angle.
  • After installation, the trap can be easily removed for clearing blockages etc without disturbing the rest of the pipe run.

One disadvantage of the 'P' trap is that it requires a fair amount of room around the waste outlet.

We usually use p-traps,its also more easy in troubleshoting or clogging

chetan sharma
par chetan sharma , Senior project engineer , trinity engineering services

i would recommend p trap as  they are free for water to flow through it ,in case some one flushes tissue it is gonna be difficult flushing it out in s trap

Craig Gillett
par Craig Gillett , Plumber , Graham Anderson Plumbing

Either trap is fine. The only difference is what sort of effect the architect or engineer would prefer. A pipe that comes out of a wall or one that come out from the floor.

More Questions Like This