Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

Which is a Cause to issue a NCR ? 1. Approved shop drawing not followed 2. Unapproved Material used. 3.Specification not followed. 4. All the above.

user-image
Question ajoutée par Anjum Jamal , QA QC Engineer , Khatib & Alami
Date de publication: 2015/09/18
Baris Celik
par Baris Celik , project Quality Control Manager , Neom Green Hydrogen Company

All the above is the answer             

Vicente Omictin
par Vicente Omictin , Civil Engineer , Saudi Oger Ltd.

My answer is no.4 which is all of the above,

 

Gary Abbott
par Gary Abbott , Superintendent Coatings & Insulation , Kellogg Brown and Root-JKC

The only time I would issue an NCR would be for number2. All of the rest can be rectified on the shop floor. The wrong materials can constitue a major NCR in that they could cause failure etc.

NCR's are not to be used just to make a point as an inspector. Our job is to complete survellience, observe, monitor, inspect and mentor those who need it. I would rather fix a problem in house than have to go through all the paperwork an NCR creates unecessarily.

My opinion is all.

Sayeed Ahmed Shaikh
par Sayeed Ahmed Shaikh , Quality Assurance Supervisor , Gandour

Option4 (All of the above)

Yhon Garcia
par Yhon Garcia , Construction Supervisor , CONSORCIO PALDACA, C.A.

Unquestionably all non-conformities.

Failure to comply with the plans and specifications, do not use those listed above materials, everything is out of compliance with quality standards. No it is meeting customer requirements.

Selvam Sekar
par Selvam Sekar , Mechanical Engineer , carillion

Approved shop drawing not followed,Unapproved material used,Specification not followed.

Khaled Bahbouh
par Khaled Bahbouh , QCM , Montagi Varna co.

In order to avvoid later problems is better to issue NCRs for all point.

While if is OK for you i think is possible to ask for deviation report (request) for1 and2 so if client approve will be OK also for you.

For point number3 i think you have to issue NCR.

alexandru tapu
par alexandru tapu , group leader of laboratories , Daewoo Mangalia Shipyard

More :1. modifications not issued by Design Team and Production works without last modifications requested by owner/client - here NCR it's mandatory because the system does not work properly

           2. not following the procedures - NCR must to be solved by Production

           3. working with measuring and monitoring equipment not valid - recalibration it's mandatory and must to be solved by Production with Laboratory

Mohamed Sayed Abd El-Aziz
par Mohamed Sayed Abd El-Aziz , Projects Manager , Rawabi Butec

NCR may be issued due to all mentioned reasons.

Javed Ahmed Laghari
par Javed Ahmed Laghari , Assistant Resident Engineer , National Development Consultants (NDC).

An Non Conformance Report can be issued to contractor if he not follow any one which you have mentioned above.

Muhammad Saey
par Muhammad Saey , Senior Veterinary Doctor , PAFN Public Autority for Food and Nutrition

Choice number4. All of the above are NC.

More Questions Like This