Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

Can we learn Automation (PLC, SCADA ... ) only by watching related videos on Youtube ?

user-image
Question ajoutée par Hassan Idami
Date de publication: 2016/03/04
Yehia Adlouni
par Yehia Adlouni , Engineering Maintenance Manager , Birchwood Foods

Yes you can, but you need to practice it too in some kinds of simulation kits. You should have some simulators so you'll get the best knowledge & capability.

Mubashir Ahmed Ansari
par Mubashir Ahmed Ansari , Maintenance Engineer & QHSE Coordinator (Instrument & Control) , Lucky Cement Limited

Yes you can learn by watching videos but only for a limited extent, to get proficient you need to do practices.because automation is a game of practices more practices more proficiency and more methods to do the same tasks. Now for practice you should have some hardware(plc and accessories) and software to make some prototypes. or by simulators you also can learn but not all.

 

Kaleem Ullah
par Kaleem Ullah , ACHIEVEMENT

Yes. you can but not only watching. if you watch and then try to practice it with simple projects in your home you can get more of it. 

Hasan Zainy
par Hasan Zainy , Control / Instrumentation Filed Service Engineer , GE

I agree with the others. Short answer, maybe you can learn some but not master the knowledge gain in certain product from specific manufacturing if you did not work on them or have a lab simulation. The on job training (ojt) is very important step to master engineer.

It is also base on what is your previous experience. Fresh engineer will gain a lot of knowledge from video on YouTube if he/she never knows about plc even if the video speak about the basic. On other hand experience engineer who know plc, will required more and deeper knowledge from the video. So seeing 100 video on general plc basic will not give more skill it is only review of the skill. For example, the person will compere x product with y. How to configure digital input Port on the new plc with the old plc I have experience with. Where as a person who never know about plc might add digital input information to his or her information.

The answers also change if you are working in Adecmia University as prof. In academic university. Where they have a lot of theory experience with very little industrial experience. I know one prof who had a book on DCS but have little experience on industrial point of view. This prof might design system but he might not able to do engineer do.

 

هاشم المشارقة
par هاشم المشارقة , Key Account Manager , Advanced United Systems Ltd. ( A member of Taj Holding Group)

I think you should got train practical on any brand to got the required skills.

Because the real world not look like the simulation either emulation.

Mudassir Mubin Baig
par Mudassir Mubin Baig , Network Engineer , Saima Packaging Pvt. Ltd.

All of my friends answer perfectly right.

You need to have some practical experience as well.

But yes..... you can learn the technique.

NIHAD  Ali
par NIHAD Ali , Maintenance and Project Manager , Younexa Egypt

its very difficult. but you can learn the basics only. you must make program and run it to see the all process makes by your hand.

 

MUBASHIR AHMED KHAN MOHAMMED
par MUBASHIR AHMED KHAN MOHAMMED , Senior Engineer , Sendan International

The youtube videos are more than enough, but practice with demos meanwhile. u will get good idea, but real time experience is more interesting......

Ahmed Mustafa
par Ahmed Mustafa , Electrical Sections Manager , Coca-Cola Egypt

Yes, you will learn but if you want to have the experience you must practice

More Questions Like This