Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

What preferred programs of engineering design and is the closest of programs manual results 1-Robot 2-Etabs 3-Safe 4-Sap 5-Advance Concrete?

user-image
Question ajoutée par زياد المدهون , Field Researcher , The interests of the municipalities of the coast
Date de publication: 2016/03/14
خيرة خليل
par خيرة خليل , مهندسة مدنية , مكتب الدراسات المعمارية والعمرانية مهدي حمزة

 

I think that -Robot- is the program favored by engineers for engineering design

mohamed magdy
par mohamed magdy , مهندس تصميم انشائي , البيت العصري للاستشارات الهندسية

 Etab is good at earthquake result . Safe is good at slabs and  footing . SAP is general programs but its  good at special building such as tanks , archs .....    

Utilisateur supprimé
par Utilisateur supprimé

I think Etabs is more accurate for long buildings design ,, 

Thanks for invitation ..

Ahmed Taha abdellah
par Ahmed Taha abdellah , Civil Site Manger , Elsewedy Electric T&D

I know very well about SAP ,Etab and Safe but others no 

A bout sap and etab all results are mainly same and no big difference between them in results but the different is in the use like sap you can design tanks ,shells and bridges  many different types of unique buildings  , For  Etab is good at earthquake loads and high rise 3D modeling and results  is accurate . 

For safe is design horizontal elements like slab and foundation you can not make stories and levels . and it is results in slab and foundation is better than etab and safe 

So you can make full design by using the etab for design columns , walls and beams and all members resist earthquakes loads  and the safe for slab and foundation and the sap for shell and unique buildings  

Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi
par Ahmed Mohamed Ayesh Sarkhi , Shared Services Supervisor , Saudi Musheera Co. Ltd.

sorry i'm not expert on this filed

 

mohamed abd el hamid abd alla elfarran elfaran
par mohamed abd el hamid abd alla elfarran elfaran , مهندس مدنى , مكتب العطيشان الهندسى

iapologize for the answer and thanks and appreciation

Would you like to get a robotic representation there? I call on Iran. See our website sadrarobot.com

Mushreq Abdulmajeed
par Mushreq Abdulmajeed , Senior Project Supervisor , Lagoon Spring Company

I am sorry I dont have any Idea 

Noura Salah Eldin
par Noura Salah Eldin , Interior Fit Out Engineer , MANGO-GROUP

i'm sorry these programs are not my specialization

Eng Ahmed Elsharkawy
par Eng Ahmed Elsharkawy , Civil Engineering Project Manager , Altwijry office

i agree with eng. mohamed magdy 

Momin  Qotqot
par Momin Qotqot , Civil Project Engineer , Al Shams general contracting

,i preferred the sap program because it more suitable for general cases 

More Questions Like This