Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

If the cost of land is very high which system would be preferred Gas insulated(GIS) or Air insulated(AIS) system?

user-image
Question added by Muhammad Usman , Assistant Manager Operations , Lahore Electric Supply Company
Date Posted: 2016/08/01
Muhammad Qasim
by Muhammad Qasim , Senior Electrical Engineer , Energy Associates (SMC Ptv.) Ltd.

Infect, GIS needs less space than the AIS because Gases (like SF6) provides better insulation than the Air, therefore its better option to go for AIS instead of GIS. But this is the case if you consider the price of land only.

With GIS, there are further extra O&M and Environmental constraints those require attention of an Engineer before taking the decision. Overall, GIS is best option as long as SF6 is there in the Market.

Regards,

Hanan Tariq
by Hanan Tariq , Internee , Wapda

in brief , GIS system is best

Syed Mujtaba Hassan
by Syed Mujtaba Hassan , Deputy Manager | Trans Real Time Operation | Power System Analysis Studies Engineer , K-Electric Limited

Gas Insulated System should be preferred in the case of high Land cost.

Aneesh Shandilya
by Aneesh Shandilya , Manager/ Lead Electrical , Orpic

If the cost of land is high, then GIS will be preferred over the AIS. GIS is having following advantages:

  • requires less space (up to% less that Air Insulated)
  • is safer in operation
  • has overall lower system loses
  • has higher protection against ambient conditions
  • is more reliable

However there are some limitations wrt AIS:

  • AIS is cheaper
  • Maintenance is less complex than GIS
  • Spares are cheap

 However when there is imitation of space, GIS is the choice.

Bilal Abid
by Bilal Abid , Management Trainee (Electrical) , PTCL

A GIS is mostly used where space is expensive or not available,AIS requires meters of air insulation to do what SF6 can do in centimeters.

RADU ONIGA
by RADU ONIGA , Design Engineer , S.C.CAROM S.A.Onesti

If the cost of land is very high system  Gas insulated(GIS) is preffered to Air insulated(AIS) system?

Jeet Shah
by Jeet Shah , Procurement Engineer , Polypower Trading LLC

Gas insulated system is suitable.

More Questions Like This