Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

There is Main difference between IFRS [International Financial Reporting Standards] and Saudi GAAP [Generally Accepted Accounting Principles] ?

Substantial differences //// there is Main difference between IFRS [International Financial Reporting Standards] and Saudi GAAP [Generally Accepted Accounting Principles] ?

user-image
Question ajoutée par Mahfouz Abdellatif CMA FMVA , Senior Consultant - Financial Accounting & Advisory Services , Andersen in Saudi Arabia
Date de publication: 2017/06/14
Danish  ali
par Danish ali , Accountant Manager , ASIANDEVS

Yes, there are key differences between IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards) and Saudi GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles in Saudi Arabia). While both aim to provide transparent and reliable financial reporting, there are some distinctions in the accounting treatments and regulations between the two. Below are the main differences: 1. Adoption and Global Use IFRS: Used internationally in over 140 countries, including the EU, Canada, Australia, and most of Asia. Saudi GAAP: Primarily used in Saudi Arabia, though it has been aligned with IFRS since 2017 for public companies, with some local adaptations. 2. Measurement of Financial Statements IFRS: Emphasizes fair value accounting for certain assets and liabilities, especially in areas like financial instruments and investment property. Saudi GAAP: Historically had a greater reliance on historical cost rather than fair value, though recent standards have moved closer to IFRS in this area. 3. Revenue Recognition IFRS: Follows a more principles-based approach with the IFRS 15 standard for revenue recognition, focusing on performance obligations and contract terms. Saudi GAAP: Previously followed a more rules-based approach and was less aligned with IFRS on the timing and criteria for recognizing revenue. However, recent updates have moved it closer to IFRS. 4. Leases IFRS: Under IFRS 16, leases are recognized on the balance sheet as both a right-of-use asset and a lease liability, impacting the income statement. Saudi GAAP: Leases were historically treated differently, particularly for operating leases, where lease expenses were recognized on a straight-line basis without balance sheet recognition. Saudi GAAP now follows similar lease recognition guidelines to IFRS 16 for listed companies. 5. Presentation of Financial Statements IFRS: Offers flexibility in presentation but requires specific formats for the balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement. IFRS also requires more detailed disclosures about financial performance. Saudi GAAP: Has more prescriptive formats for the presentation of financial statements. While it has adopted some elements of IFRS for better transparency, local regulatory requirements still dictate certain formats. 6. Consolidation and Group Accounting IFRS: Under IFRS 10, a control-based model is used for determining when and how subsidiaries should be consolidated into the group’s financial statements. Saudi GAAP: Previously, there were some differences in how control and consolidation were defined. However, Saudi GAAP now largely aligns with IFRS on consolidation principles. 7. Financial Instruments and Impairment IFRS: Under IFRS 9, financial instruments are classified and measured based on their business model and the cash flow characteristics. Impairment is recognized using an expected credit loss model. Saudi GAAP: The treatment of financial instruments and impairment was historically less detailed than IFRS. However, Saudi GAAP has increasingly aligned with IFRS 9, especially regarding the impairment of financial assets. 8. Tax Treatment IFRS: Focuses on the recognition of deferred tax assets and liabilities using a balance sheet approach, with a focus on temporary differences. Saudi GAAP: Similar to IFRS in recognizing deferred taxes, but there can be differences in the specific tax treatments and the calculation of tax bases. 9. Intangible Assets IFRS: Under IAS 38, intangible assets are recognized if they are identifiable and provide future economic benefits. Revaluation of intangible assets is permitted under certain circumstances. Saudi GAAP: Previously had different rules for recognizing and measuring intangible assets, but it has become more aligned with IFRS in recent years. 10. Transition and Adoption IFRS: Regularly updated with new standards and amendments (e.g., IFRS 17 for insurance contracts, IFRS 9 for financial instruments). Adoption is mandatory for public companies. Saudi GAAP: Has been in transition since Saudi Arabia adopted IFRS for listed companies in 2017. Non-listed companies were given an option to adopt IFRS or continue with Saudi GAAP. Over time, Saudi GAAP has been converging with IFRS. Conclusion: IFRS is the global standard and provides more flexibility, with a strong emphasis on fair value accounting and principles-based guidance. Saudi GAAP is tailored for the Saudi market, with a history of being more rules-based but has made significant strides toward alignment with IFRS since the adoption of IFRS for listed companies. Both frameworks aim to ensure accurate and reliable financial reporting, but IFRS is more globally recognized, while Saudi GAAP reflects local regulations and practices.

KAPIL GAIKWAD
par KAPIL GAIKWAD , Sr. Finance Associates , Atmantan wellness center

IFRS is a principle of the standard-based approach and is used internationally, while GAAP is a rule-based system compiled in the U.S. The IASB does not set GAAP, nor does it have any legal authority over GAAP.

Moheet Khan
par Moheet Khan , General Accountant , Subway Fast Food

The key differences between GAAP and IFRS include: GAAP is a framework based on legal authority while IFRS is based on a principles-based approach. GAAP is more detailed and prescriptive while IFRS is more high-level and flexible. GAAP requires more disclosures while IFRS requires fewer disclosures

shahid Shareef
par shahid Shareef , Assistant Accountant , seminal soft

  1. Adoption and Applicability: IFRS is widely adopted by many countries around the world, including over 120 countries, while Saudi GAAP is specifically designed for accounting practices in Saudi Arabia.

  2. Regulatory Authority: IFRS is issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), an independent international standard-setting body. In Saudi Arabia, the Saudi Organization for Certified Public Accountants (SOCPA) is responsible for issuing accounting standards and guidelines, which form the basis for Saudi GAAP.

  3. Format and Structure: IFRS follows a principle-based approach, providing broad guidelines and objectives, with some specific requirements. Saudi GAAP, on the other hand, tends to have more detailed rules and specific guidelines for various accounting treatments.

  4. Financial Statement Presentation: IFRS places greater emphasis on the fair presentation of financial statements, focusing on providing relevant and reliable information. Saudi GAAP may have specific requirements or formats for financial statement presentation that differ from IFRS.

  5. Islamic Finance: Saudi Arabia has a significant presence of Islamic finance, and as a result, Saudi GAAP incorporates specific accounting principles and guidelines to address the unique aspects of Islamic finance transactions, such as Shariah compliance and profit-sharing arrangements. IFRS, being a global standard, does not specifically address Islamic finance in the same level of detail.

ZULFIQAR ALI
par ZULFIQAR ALI , Financial Management Specialist , THE WORLD BANK PROGRAMME UNDER FEDERAL DIRECTORATE OF IMMUNIZATION, M/O NHSRC, ISD

IFRS are developed by international body which are being updated by the said body.  Saudi GAAP are customised accounting standard being updated by it also.

Gilgit baltistan Adventure Lover
par Gilgit baltistan Adventure Lover , Marketing Manager , Saadat GB Constrsction Company And Property Advisor

GAAP lists assets in decreasing order of liquidity (i.e. current assets before non-current assets), whereas IFRS reports assets in increasing order of liquidity (i.e. non-current assets before current assets.

Michael Mulwa
par Michael Mulwa , Audit Associate , Kenya Certified Accountants of Lenya

IFRS are international standards while GAAP are nationally set principles by the national accounting bodies to guide the accounting undertakings

Kugonza Bernard
par Kugonza Bernard , Head Of Finance , Kampala Pharmaceutical Industries (1996) Ltd

IFRS are international Financial reporting standards that are applicable at a global level or internationally. This therefore implies that all companies irrespective of their domicile are required to implement and apply the reporting standards that are required by IFRS. This is a good move because it puts all the financial statements of the different entities irrespective of their location into the same yardstick and therefore provided a more accurate comparison of financial statements and reports of these entities.  The saudi GAAP ( Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) are designed to provide a more uniform reporting standard for companies or entities that are specificlly based in saudi Arabia. This therefore means that comparability of the financial statements for companies that follow the saudi GAAP and IFRS will be more onerous than the case would have been if they were prepared under a similar standard

Muhammad Ahmed Shahid
par Muhammad Ahmed Shahid , Chief Accountant , Akun Logistic Services

IFRS stands for International Financial Reporting Standars issued by IASB which are applicable at international level for public limited companies. Saudi GAAP are the generally accepted accounting principles issued by the Saudi Accounting body but the Saudi GAAP are alos indeed in line with international GAAP. Saudi GAAP are applicable on Saudi companies only while IFRS are applicable on companies at international level.

Mahmoud Hassan
par Mahmoud Hassan , Senior Internal Auditor , We - Telecom Egypt

IFRS is internationally accepted code of accounting practice. Its like an yardstick. On the other hand Saudi GAAP is applicable for Saudi economy only ofcourse the platform taken from is International GAAP. Saudi may have its own GAAP for its Company's . 

More Questions Like This